RAND Health Abstract

Appropriateness of Acute Medical Care for the Elderly: An Analysis of the Literature.

Brook RH, Kamberg CJ, Mayer-Oakes A, Beers MH, Raube K, Steiner A. Health Policy, Vol. 14, 1990, pp. 225-242 (Available as RAND N-3371-HHS.)

This Note analyzes the literature regarding appropriateness of acute care provided to the elderly. The authors identified 17 articles that explicitly cited appropriate or inappropriate care (including undercare, overcare, and misuse) provided in hospital and ambulatory settings and for procedures, and 19 articles that presented data on the appropriateness of medication use in the elderly. Virtually every study found at least double-digit levels of inappropriate care. Perhaps as much as one-fifth to one-quarter of acute hospital services or procedures were felt to be used for equivocal or inappropriate reasons, and two-fifths to one-half of the medications studied were overused in outpatients. The few studies that examined underuse or misuse of services also documented the existence of these phenomena. This was especially true for the ambulatory care of chronic physical and mental conditions and concerned the use of low-cost technologies (visits, preventive services, some medications). Thus, the authors conclude that there appears to be a substantial problem in matching acute services to the needs of elderly patients. This mismatch occurs both in terms of overuse and underuse, at least for areas where research has been conducted.