Supreme Court Upholds the Affordable Care Act: What the Experts Are Saying

June 28, 2012

Today's Supreme Court decision to uphold most of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA)—and most notably, the individual mandate that all Americans purchase health insurance or pay a financial penalty—is likely the most significant health care-related ruling in U.S. history.

When President Barack Obama signed the bill into law in March 2010, the American health care system seemed destined for sweeping reform. Yet constitutional challenges soon surfaced, with two such cases climbing the judicial hierarchy and landing in the Supreme Court, threatening the President's signature legislative achievement.

Now that key provisions of the president's reform have survived the process and a mixed ruling on Medicaid expansion has prevailed, what lies ahead for health care in America? RAND experts sound off in the wake of the Court's momentous decision.

Future of Medicaid Still Uncertain

Christine Eibner

With most of the key provisions of the Affordable Care Act upheld, we expect close to 30 million Americans to gain health insurance coverage. Yet the part of the ruling dealing with Medicaid is significant. We don't know how many states will respond, and it will take thoughtful, quantitative analysis to gain insight into this. Our next challenge will be to analyze the effects of states opting out of Medicaid expansion, and how this might influence insurance coverage, exchange enrollment, and federal spending on subsidies.

Christine Eibner, economist

Learn More

Program Design Key to Achieving ACA's Goals

Cheryl Damberg

As federal and state policymakers move to implement the ACA, there are a plethora of decisions that must be made about how to structure the program elements. These decisions and the evolution of health care reform can be improved by the independent, objective analyses that RAND can provide. We can help identify best approaches to program design and implementation, and how to assess the impact of the ACA in achieving better quality, lower costs, and improved health. RAND's work in the area of pay-for-performance and value-based purchasing is one example of how RAND is helping policymakers design incentive programs to improve quality and lower costs.

Cheryl L. Damberg, senior policy researcher

Learn More

With Ruling Settled, Reform Can Begin

Peter Hussey

The ACA contains a myriad of provisions to reduce health care costs and improve quality independent of the mandate. For example, reforms have advanced primary care in ‘patient-centered medical homes’ and ‘bundled payments’ for common episodes of care have been taking root, but could potentially accelerate in the private sector with federal funding confirmed. Now that the uncertainty of the Supreme Court decision has been lifted, transformation of health care delivery can move rapidly ahead.

Peter Hussey, policy researcher

Learn More

Supreme Court Not the Only Group Whose Decisions Matter

The passage of the law and this ruling are the start of health care reform, not the end. There are now many decisions to be made. State governments need to make preparations for the insurance exchanges and the expansion of Medicaid. Health insurance companies must ensure their offerings are in compliance with the law. Businesses should assess the impact of the new options on their employees to determine if they should continue to offer health insurance. Health care providers need to assess whether they have the capacity to provide care to as many as 30 million newly insured Americans. Finally, individuals should look at the new options that will be open to them in 2014.

— Carter C. Price, mathematician

Learn More

  • Report

    Federal Drug Discount Program Faces Challenges as It Expands Under Health Reform

    Aug 12, 2014

    A federal program that provides billions in drug discounts to safety net hospitals and other health care providers is expanding under health care reform, but divergent views on the purpose and future scope of the program create uncertainty for safety net providers and drug manufacturers.

  • Blog

    A Summer Reading List for Congress

    Jul 31, 2014

    No matter how policymakers spend their break—meeting with home-state constituents, traveling abroad with congressional delegations, or spending time with family—this summer reading list contains policy ideas, including health-related reading on dementia policy and Medicaid, that can help them hit the ground running when they return.

  • Blog

    RAND Helps to Develop From Coverage to Care, a New CMS Initiative

    Jul 29, 2014

    Health coverage is a means to an end: the aim is to help more Americans use their coverage to access routine primary care and preventive services. For many of the newly insured, however, the leap between obtaining insurance and establishing a regular source of care is substantial.

  • Blog

    The ACA's Opportunity to Improve Care for Substance Use Disorders

    Jul 28, 2014

    The Affordable Care Act (ACA) will significantly increase coverage for the publicly funded treatment of substance use disorders. But in order to maximize the benefit to patients, families, and society, it's critical to invest in the development, validation, and use of performance measures.

  • Research Brief

    Will Heath Care Reform Affect Disability Insurance Claiming?

    Jul 10, 2014

    By enabling access to affordable private health insurance and expanding access to subsidized public health insurance, the Affordable Care Act alters the calculus of disability claiming decisions. Research offers empirical evidence that, on net, disability applications are likely to decrease.