Standards Based Education Reform

The goal of standards-based reform is to establish objective metrics to assess student performance and teacher effectiveness, using standardized instructional materials and testing: Individual performance is measured against a set of common criteria rather than in relation to other students. RAND research considers the role of standards-based education reform, including the United States' No Child Left Behind law, in shaping global education policy.

Research conducted by: RAND Education; RAND-Qatar Policy Institute

Featured at RAND

Reauthorizing No Child Left Behind: Facts and Recommendations

Congress and the Obama administration should use the upcoming reauthorization of the No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 to promote more consistent and rigorous academic standards across states, as well as more consistent and relevant teacher qualification requirements.

All Items (29)

MULTIMEDIA

No Child Left Behind: Ten Years Later — Jan 6, 2012

Laura Hamilton discusses what has been learned in the ten years since the No Child Left Behind Act was signed into law in January 2002, including recommendations for addressing key limitations as Congress considers reauthorization.

MULTIMEDIA

What We Know About Measuring School Performance — Jun 29, 2011

At this June 2011 RAND Policy Circle event in Pittsburgh, a selection of RAND's top experts in education policy shared fresh, evidence-based perspectives on measuring school performance.

JOURNAL ARTICLE

K-12 Education Reform in Qatar — Jun 21, 2011

In 2002, Qatar began implementing a standards-based K–12 reform that established new publicly-funded, privately-operated 'Independent schools.' The reform built on four principles: autonomy, accountability, variety, and choice. Early data reveal more student-centered classroom practices and higher student achievement in the new schools. But as all Ministry schools convert to independent status, many challenges remain to achieving the…

MULTIMEDIA

Why We Need to Study the Tutors Audio Commentary — Jan 19, 2010

Based on the results of statewide standardized tests, more than 15 percent of U.S. schools are in need of improvement. The students attending these schools need help.

REPORT

Ending Social Promotion Without Leaving Children Behind: The Case of New York City — Oct 14, 2009

The New York City Department of Education's test-based promotion and retention policy, which identifies and provides support for struggling students, has demonstrated positive effects for student achievement in fifth grade that continue into seventh grade.

RESEARCH BRIEF

Lessons Learned from Developing and Implementing the Qatar Student Assessment System (Arabic version) — Jul 29, 2009

This research brief summarizes the development of a standards-based student assessment system in Qatar, lessons for policymakers in Qatar and elsewhere, and challenges in aligning the assessment with future changes in the curriculum standards.

RESEARCH BRIEF

Lessons Learned from Developing and Implementing the Qatar Student Assessment System — Jul 1, 2009

This research brief summarizes the development of a standards-based student assessment system in Qatar, lessons for policymakers in Qatar and elsewhere, and challenges in aligning the assessment with future changes in the curriculum standards.

JOURNAL ARTICLE

Standards-Based Reform in the United States: History, Research, and Future Directions — Feb 5, 2009

Summarizes the history of the standards-based reform movement in the United States and discusses how the movement has shaped educators' practices and students' outcomes.

MULTIMEDIA

Ending Social Promotion: Examining the Effects of NYC's 5th-Grade Promotion Policy — Jan 18, 2009

In this Congressional Briefing held on October 19, 2009, researchers Jennifer McCombs and Lou Mariano discuss RAND's recently published evaluation of a test-based promotion policy implemented by the New York City Department of Education. The findings will be of interest as many states and school districts are implementing test-based requirements for promotion at key transitional points in students' schooling careers, thus ending the…

NEWS RELEASE

Study Finds That 'No Child Left Behind' Accountability Systems Are Largely in Place, But Act's Promises Remain Uncertain — Nov 19, 2007

After five years of effort, states have implemented most of the test-based accountability requirements of the No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) of 2001, and now must focus their efforts on improving poor-performing schools that have been identified.

RESEARCH BRIEF

A New System for K-12 Education in Qatar (Arabic version) — Oct 31, 2007

This research brief highlights aspects of Phase I (2001-04) of Qatar's K-12 reform initiative, Education for a New Era, based on RAND's experiences in this multi-participant effort to build a world-class standards- and choice-based education system.

REPORT

Education for a New Era, Executive Summary: Design and Implementation of K-12 Education Reform in Qatar — Oct 29, 2007

Presents an overview of Phase I (2001-2004) of Qatar’s bold K-12 education reform initiative, Education for a New Era, based on RAND’s experiences in this ambitious, multi-participant effort. RAND examined Qatar’s existing education system, recommended options for building a world-class system, and supported implementation of the chosen option, which is based on internationally benchmarked curriculum standards…

NEWS RELEASE

RAND Study Finds Qatar Successfully Implements Redesign of Education System — Apr 12, 2007

April 12, 2007 news release: RAND Study Finds Qatar Successfully Implements Redesign of Education System.

REPORT

Qatar Successfully Implements Redesign of Education System — Apr 12, 2007

In only a few years, the State of Qatar has successfully implemented a bold redesign of its K-12 education system, incorporating school autonomy, variety in curriculum, parental choice and accountability measures.

RESEARCH BRIEF

A New System for K-12 Education in Qatar — Apr 8, 2007

This research brief highlights aspects of Phase I (2001-04) of Qatar's K-12 reform initiative, Education for a New Era, based on RAND's experiences in this multi-participant effort to build a world-class standards- and choice-based education system.

JOURNAL ARTICLE

Testing for Accountability in K-12 — Dec 31, 2005

REPORT

External Audiences for Test-Based Accountability: The Perspectives of Journalists and Foundations — Dec 20, 2004

Little has been written about the interaction of the No Child Left Behind Act with external audiences that have no formal connections with the schools. This study focuses on print journalists and foundation program officers, who frequently use data from schools and districts in their work. The authors summarize the data needs of the two groups and offer advice to producers of performance reports and analyses and to the external consumers…

COMMENTARY

Parents of Schoolchildren: Start Your Information Engines — Oct 10, 2004

Published commentary by RAND staff.

REPORT

Organizational Improvement and Accountability: Lessons for Education from Other Sectors — May 2, 2004

Describes accountability models in the manufacturing, job training, legal, and health care sectors; summarizes their effectiveness; and draws specific lessons for educators.

My RAND ?

Saved Items

Recommended