Are Charter Schools a Good Option in the Gulf States?

Science student and teacher

Charter schools are widely discussed as an alternative to traditional public schools in the quest to improve K–12 education. Nationwide, charter schools will be an important element in the debate over reauthorizing the Elementary and Secondary Education Act — better known as No Child Left Behind.

In the Gulf States, urban school districts like New Orleans have looked to charter schools to improve the support they provide to children who often face many disadvantages. The Mississippi legislature debated HB 888, the Public Charter School Act of 2012, this spring and will likely bring up the subject again this fall. And the authorization of charter schools remains a priority for Alabama's governor and Republican leadership in the House and Senate.

For nearly two decades, RAND has been conducting research on choice-based education reforms, including charter schools. The RAND Gulf States Policy Institute developed this policy spotlight to focus attention on our objective, evidence-based research and to help Gulf States and other education policymakers make the right decisions for their communities.

  • teacher and student at chalkboard

    Perceptions of Traditional and Charter Schools in New Orleans

    Sep 30, 2011

    After Hurricane Katrina, New Orleans replaced the city's existing school system with a decentralized choice-based system of both charter and district-run schools. An examination of principal, teacher, and parent surveys found many similarities between charter and traditional schools' performance but greater satisfaction among charter school parents with their children's schools, as well as more perceived choices.

  • Achievement,Alum Bay,Bachelor's Degree,Beauty And Health,Black,Blue,Celebration,Ceremony,Close-up,Copy Space,Cut Out,Diploma,Education,Expertise,Fashion,Finishing,Graduation,Hat,High School,Horizontal,Intelligence,Isolated,Isolated On White,Learning,Macro,Mortar Board,Nobody,Red,Remote,Ribbon,Rolled Up,School,Scroll,Scroll Shape,Single Object,Studio Shot,Success,Tassel,The End,University,White,White Background,Wisdom,Yellow,cap,college,college degree,degree,masters degree

    What Are the Effects of Charter Schools on Educational Attainment in Eight States?

    Mar 18, 2009

    Along with the growth of the charter school movement has come contentious debate about its effects on both charter students and those in nearby traditional public schools. This study helps determine why previous research has drawn differing conclusions through its examination of charter schools' effect on overall educational attainment.

  • teacher calling on students

    Understanding the Role of Charter Schools in Improving Education

    Nov 17, 2009

    Charter schools are increasing in numbers as alternatives to traditional public schools, and research shows some associated positive effects on student attainment. RAND recommends that the federal government support further investigation.

  • Female Students Showing diplomas

    Charter School Students in Chicago Enjoy Better Graduation, College Entry Rates

    May 7, 2008

    Chicago's multi-grade charter high schools (those serving students in grades 7-12, 6-12 or K-12) appear to improve their students' chances of graduating and attending college, as compared with the city's traditional public high schools.

  • children in school classroom

    What Do We Know About Vouchers and Charter Schools?

    Aug 16, 2007

    Vouchers and charter schools are two of the most prominent and far-reaching forms of family-choice policies currently in evidence in the nation's schools. An updated version of the report Rhetoric Versus Reality takes a detailed look at what is known about the effects of school choice.

  • two male students looking at a laptop

    Do Charter Schools Close the Achievement Gap in Urban Districts?

    Oct 20, 2006

    Many urban leaders, including mayors and school district superintendents, have initiated charter schools as a mechanism of improving learning for disadvantaged students. An analysis of the effect charter schools are having in two major urban districts in California, however, shows that achievement scores in charters are keeping pace, but not exceeding those in traditional public schools.