In Focus: Private Military Contractors

Prepared by the RAND Corporation | August 2023

Members of the Wagner Group pose for a photo circa 2018 in Syria.  Photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine.

Members of the Wagner Group in Syria circa 2018
(photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine)

This newsletter captures a selection of open-source material on Private Military and Security Companies (PMSCs) during July 2023. The United Nations defines PMSC as a corporate entity which provides on a compensatory basis military and/or security services by physical persons and/or legal entities. Military services include specialized services related to military actions, including strategic planning, intelligence, investigation, land, sea or air reconnaissance, flight operations of any type, manned or unmanned, satellite surveillance, any kind of knowledge transfer with military applications, material and technical support to armed forces and other related activities. Security services include armed guarding or protection of buildings, installations, property and people, any kind of knowledge transfer with security and policing applications, development and implementation of informational security measures and other related activities. In the context of this newsletter, malign activities are those activities undertaken by a PMSC which are illegal, destabilizing, or escalatory. The RAND Corporation seeks credible open-source material and curates but does not verify the content of the open-source material in this monthly summary with the support of U.S. government foreign assistance funding to raise awareness of the activities of PMSCs.

Africa (sub-Sahara)  |  East Asia and the Pacific  |  Europe and Eurasia  |  Western Hemisphere

Africa (sub-Sahara)

Kleptocratic Cooperation in Africa: How Russia and China Undermine Democracy

July 27, 2023  |  National Endowment for Democracy

The two essays in this report highlight ways in which the authoritarian regimes of Russia and China provide surge capacity to kleptocratic networks in Africa. The first essay focuses on the Wagner Group's illicit activities in key parts of Africa, particularly on how Wagner military support offered to African kleptocrats fails to provide security and stability to the African people but rather focuses on extracting resources, advancing geopolitical goals, and serving as a cog in the authoritarian mutual support machinery. The second essay focuses on China's kleptocratic networks in Africa with a focus on the relationship between China and the Republic of the Congo (Congo-Brazzaville) with an emphasis on the ways in which Beijing facilitates the Congo's kleptocratic regime through support of the timber and extractive industries and the establishment of a Sino-Congolese Bank for Africa to help bypass Western banks to facilitate money laundering.

US Sanctions Mali’s Defence Minister, Officials Over Wagner Ties

July 24, 2023  |  Al Jazeera

According to the report, the U.S. has imposed sanctions on three Malian nationals for their role in facilitating and expanding "Wagner’s presence in Mali since December 2021.” The report claims that civilian fatalities surged by 278% since Wagner group mercenaries entered the country. The report mentions some of the malign activities of the Wagner group, including the massacre of more than 500 people in Moura in March 2022, and the forced disappearance and summary execution of several dozen civilians since December 2022.

Russia-Africa Summit Provides a Global Stage for Moscow to Puff Up Its Influence

July 24, 2023  |  The Conversation

Despite diminishing economic ties with Africa, Russia's influence on the continent has rapidly expanded since the 2019 Russia-Africa Summit, in part due to its reliance on irregular means to expand influence. These include propping up isolated, autocratic regimes through a combination of the deployment of Wagner forces, electoral interference, disinformation, and arms-for-resources deals. These tactics are destabilizing for host countries, and half of the two dozen African countries where Russia has been actively plying its influence are in conflict. This has led to a gap between the interests of African leaders and citizens, who have regularly stated that they want more democracy, job creation, and upholding of the rule of law.

Who Will Control Wagner's Empire of War and Gold?

July 24, 2023  |  The Wall Street Journal

The Kremlin is seeking to seize control of the Wagner Group's sprawling global empire. The status of the Wagner network in Africa is in flux following Wagner's mutiny, with little clarity yet about who is in control. Hundreds of Wagner fighters departed from the Central African Republic soon after the mutiny, but now dozens of fresh troops have arrived to help CAR's president secure a referendum that could extend his term. In a video recorded after the mutiny at Wagner's new base in Belarus, Prigozhin said that Africa would be a focus for the group.

Mali: New Atrocities by Malian Army, Apparent Wagner Fighters

July 24, 2023  |  Human Rights Watch

Malian armed forces and foreign fighters apparently from the Russia-linked Wagner Group have summarily executed and forcibly disappeared several dozen civilians in Mali's central region since December 2022. They also destroyed and looted civilian property and allegedly tortured detainees in an army camp. People interviewed by Human Rights Watch said that the Malian armed forces committed the abuses during military operations in response to the presence of Islamist armed groups in Ouenkoro, Séguéla, Sossobé, and Thioffol villages, in Mopti and Ségou regions. During all of the operations, except the one in Thioffol, witnesses reported the involvement of foreign non-French speaking armed men who they described as "white," "Russians", or "Wagner."

UK Sanctions Wagner Leaders Linked to African Killings and Torture

July 20, 2023  |  Africa News

The report discusses the recent sanctions imposed by the UK government on companies and individuals involved in abuses carried out by the Wagner group in the Central African Republic, Mali, and Sudan. Charges against these individuals include executions, acts of torture, and threats to peace and security. Mining and security companies providing funding and support for Wagner's operations were also sanctioned.

Wagner Troops Arrive in Central African Republic Ahead of Referendum

July 17, 2023  |  Reuters

According to the report, dozens of Wagner mercenaries have been deployed to the Central African Republic (CAR) ahead of a referendum scheduled for July 30 "that could see the president extend his term." The report noted that the recent exit of hundreds of Wagner mercenaries was a routine annual rotation of forces rather than a withdrawal.

The Wagner Group Is Expanding Its Presence on the African Continent

July 17, 2023  |  Afrique Media

The Wagner PMC is currently negotiating with several African countries regarding the provision of services. Agreements are likely to be concluded at the Russia-Africa Forum and the BRICS Forum in South Africa. There are also reports of negotiations with representatives of Asian and Latin American countries. The article notes that the Wagner Group is effective, cheap, and has experience working with African companies. This report was published by Afrique Media, a pro-Russian media company based in Cameroon.

East Asia and the Pacific

How China's Overseas Security Forces Differ from Wagner

July 01, 2023  |  The Wall Street Journal

Private, military-style security companies are an increasingly visible element of China's expanding global footprint, but, unlike the Wagner paramilitary fighting forces that are equipped for war, China's security companies primarily handle guard duties that do not require lethal weaponry. For more dangerous jobs overseas, China's security companies function like consultants, hiring and managing local staffs who might be armed. As Chinese enterprises expand internationally through its Belt and Road Initiative, Beijing has encouraged a globalizing push by commercial security firms such as Huaxin Zhongan Group, China Huawei Security Group, and Frontier Services Group's DeWe Security.

Europe and Eurasia

Is the Wagner Group a Terrorist Organization

July 26, 2023  |  Foreign Policy

Capitol Hill is considering branding the Wagner Group as a foreign terrorist organization, but the State Department, worried about implications for U.S. diplomacy in a host of African countries where Wagner is known to operate, is pushing back against this designation, according to congressional sources and former government officials. The concern is that such a move could jeopardize U.S. outreach to a handful of already unstable African countries, such as Mali and the Central African Republic, that could spiral into chaos if the Biden administration goes after Wagner too hard. Critics of the proposal argue that it could hamper humanitarian operations in countries already grappling with crises.

US Sanctions North Korean for Facilitating Arms Sales to Russia’s Wagner Group

July 21, 2023  |  NK News

The report discusses the U.S. sanctions on a North Korean, Rim Yong Hyok, for facilitating arms transfers to Russia. Rim Yong Hyok is also said to have provided "material, financial or technological support.” The report notes that about 120 individuals and entities were sanctioned for their role in facilitating Russia's "procurement of critical goods and technology." Russian PMCs were also included in the sanctions.

Private Russian Military Companies Are Multiplying – And so are the Kremlin’s Problems

July 16, 2023  |  France 24

According to the report, Russia is considering granting legal status to its some of its more than two dozen PMCs. The report mentioned Wagner Group, Convoy, Patriot, the Moran Security Group and Shchit (Shield) as some of the PMCs Russia is considering. The article adds that despite being illegal, PMCs have continued to increase in Russia because of their role in the Ukraine conflict and in Russia's foreign policy. The report mentions that PMCs have been created by different organizations including Gazprom and the Russian Orthodox Church. The report also mentions that Russia has 27 PMCs, 70% of which were created after 2014.

Western Hemisphere

Chinese Private Security Companies in Latin America

July 17, 2023  |  The Diplomat

The expanding presence of China-based companies in Latin America, and the security problems they have experienced there, creates an inherent demand for Chinese private security companies (PSCs). The proliferation of Chinese PSCs has arguably been based on the presumption that the cultural familiarity, common language, and relationships with fellow Chinese will give such companies an inside track with Chinese companies in need of protection. Authoritarian regimes like Venezuela, Cuba, and Nicaragua would be most likely to host Chinese PSCs, along with countries with large Chinese diaspora populations, such as Peru and Panama.

Contacts

Cortney Weinbaum

weinbaum@rand.org

Senior Management Scientist

Melissa Shostak

mshostak@rand.org

Research Assistant

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis.

Privacy statement | Manage your subscription

Unsubscribe

RAND Corporation

RAND Corporation. 1776 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401-3208.
RAND® is a registered trademark.