In Focus: Private Military Contractors

Prepared by the RAND Corporation | December 2023

Members of the Wagner Group pose for a photo circa 2018 in Syria. Photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine.

Members of the Wagner Group in Syria circa 2018
(photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine)

This newsletter captures a selection of open-source material on Private Military and Security Companies (PMSCs) during November 2023. The United Nations defines PMSC as a corporate entity which provides on a compensatory basis military and/or security services by physical persons and/or legal entities. Military services include specialized services related to military actions, including strategic planning, intelligence, investigation, land, sea or air reconnaissance, flight operations of any type, manned or unmanned, satellite surveillance, any kind of knowledge transfer with military applications, material and technical support to armed forces and other related activities. Security services include armed guarding or protection of buildings, installations, property and people, any kind of knowledge transfer with security and policing applications, development and implementation of informational security measures and other related activities. In the context of this newsletter, malign activities are those activities undertaken by a PMSC which are illegal, destabilizing, or escalatory. The RAND Corporation seeks credible open-source material and curates but does not verify the content of the open-source material in this monthly summary with the support of U.S. government foreign assistance funding to raise awareness of the activities of PMSCs.

Africa (sub-Sahara)  |  Europe and Eurasia

Africa (sub-Sahara)

China's Mercenaries in Africa: A Growing Threat or a Strategic Partner?

November 30, 2023  |  Military Africa

China's government has been increasingly using private security companies (PSCs) to protect its investments and interests in Africa as part of its Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Chinese PSCs hav found a profitable niche market in Africa through guarding Chinese executives and construction sites and securing Chinese vessels at sea against piracy. These PSCs are not fully "private" as they are accredited by the government, are mostly controlled by the state, and consist mainly of veterans of the People's Liberation Army. Some of the most prominent Chinese security companies in Africa are DeWe Security Service, Huaxin Zhongan, and Shanghai Zhonwei.

Salary as for "Special Military Operation" and Exemption from "Special Military Operation": The Russian Ministry of Defense Is Recruiting Paratroopers for the War for Prigozhin's "Legacy" in Africa (Зарплата как на "СВО" и освобождение от "СВО": Минобороны РФ вербует десантников для войны за "наследство" Пригожина в Африке)

November 28, 2023  |  Obozrevatel

The Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation is reportedly recruiting paratroopers for the war in Africa in an attempt to preserve the "legacy" of Yevgeny Prigozhyn and the PMC Wagner. The recruits are offered a salary similar to that they would receive by participating in the war but, at the same time, they are exempt from participation in the war in Ukraine. The group is reportedly formed by the PMC Redut.

Wagner Group Reportedly Rakes in $10 Million-a-Month from Instability in Mali

November 27, 2023  |  Business Insider Africa

The Wagner Group reportedly makes $10 million per month through its involvement in the ongoing conflict in Mali. U.S. intelligence experts believe the mercenary group is profiting from the proxy war between the Malian government and the Islamic State, which has seen hundreds of civilians killed and wounded. Mali and Russia claim that the fighters are not mercenaries but trainers assisting local troops in combating an insurgency.

The Flag of the PMC Wagner Was Raised over the Malian City of Kidal (Над малийским городом Кидал подняли флаг ЧВК "Вагнер")

November 22, 2023  |  Avia Pro

PMC Wagners have reportedly raised their flag in the city of Kidal in Mali. PMC Wagner and Malian Armed Forces allegedly captured the cities, driving the Coordination of Azawad Movements out.

The Dragon and the Bear in Africa: Stress-Testing Chinese-Russian Relations

November 09, 2023  |  Foreign Policy Research Institute

Both China and Russia operate PMSCs in Africa. Russian PMSCs operate in 31 African countries, while their Chinese counterparts operate in fifteen. Where Chinese PMSCs limit their activities to providing security for China's economic interest in Africa, Wagner's involvement has been much broader and deeper. Despite the turmoil caused by Wagner's 2023 insurrection, which has created questions regarding Wagner's future, Russia still benefits from its informal military presence, and the Kremlin will seek to preserve those advantages through a reformed, post-Prigozhin Wagner Group or other PMSCs.

Mali Rejects Claims of Targeted Killing of Civilians

November 06, 2023  |  Voice of America

Mali's ruling junta rejected as "unfounded" accusations made by the Human Rights Watch (HRW) that its soldiers and Russian Wagner Group mercenaries killed forty civilians in three operations. It also denied working with Russia's Wagner Group, without naming it. HRW reported that Malian soldiers and fighters apparently from Wagner killed forty civilians in three operations between April and September.

Europe and Eurasia

Shadow Mobilisation: Wagner Veterans Sell to the Highest Bidder

November 23, 2023  |  Intelligence Online

According to the report, former platoon leaders and captains of the "now defunct" Wagner group are selling the services of their unit members to regions and municipalities in Russia that are trying to meet the "unofficial volunteer recruitment quotas imposed by the Kremlin." Moscow as well as other resource and cash-rich regions are reportedly exploiting this opportunity. The report notes that about 40% of former Wagner mercenaries refused to join any of the "three new structures designed to accommodate them." The report mentions the "Wagner 2 + 1" concept which includes a branch headed by a former senior Wagner official loyal to the FSB, a group under a deputy minister conducting clandestine operations in Syria and Libya, and a militia, under the leadership late Yevgeny Prigozhin's son, that is free to conduct operations in Africa.

Russia Continues to Forcibly Recruit Prisoners and Migrant Workers for War in Ukraine (Part Two)

November 08, 2023  |  Jamestown Foundation

The Kremlin has broadened the recruitment of prisoners by the Russian Ministry of Defense and National Guard (Rosgvardia) in an effort to avoid launching a second wave of mass mobilization. The Defense Ministry utilizes two quasi-private military companies - Storm-Z and Redut - in recruiting and deploying more prisoners to Ukraine. Following the ban on Wagner's recruitment of prisoners, the MoD emerged as the main player in coercing prisoners to sign contracts to fight in Ukraine. The recruitment of prisoners is taking place across Russia's regions and has seemingly picked up in recent months.

Chechen Leader Kadyrov Says Ex-Wagner Fighters are Training with His Forces

November 06, 2023  |  Reuters

Chechen leader, Ramzan Kadyrov, announced "a big group of" former Wagner group mercenaries have commenced training with his Akhmat special forces. The report adds that it is not clear if the former Wagner mercenaries would remain with the Chechen forces when the training is over. The report mentions that the future of the Wagner group has been uncertain following the death of its leader, Yevgeny Prigozhin, but adds that Russia has ordered members of the group to sign an oath of allegiance to the state.

"The Bearded Circus Lasts a Year and a Half." Where Do the Fighters of the PMC Wagner Go? ("Бородатый цирк длится полтора года". Куда уходят бойцы ЧВК "Вагнер")

November 02, 2023  |  BBC Russian

The article discusses the options for continuing their mercenary activities that former PMC Wagner fighters face. One possibility is to move to PMC Regut, following one of the former commanders, Andrei Troshev. Some of the fighters instead decided to sign contracts with the Ministry of Defense. These fighters will continue serving in Syria and Libya. The third option is to sign contracts with the Russian National Guard and work under the command of Pavel Prigozhin in Mali, Sudan, and the Central African Republic.

Faith Leaders Highlight Russian Religious Persecution in Occupied Ukraine

November 02, 2023  |  Atlantic Council

Since the Russian invasion of Ukraine first began in 2014, Russian aggression has included often-overlooked religious elements accompanied by the cynical use of religious narratives weaponized by Russian President Vladimir Putin and Russian Orthodox Patriarch Krill. The Russian Orthodox Church has emerged as a prominent supporter of the war, with Russian Patriarch Kirill backing the invasion and assuring Russian soldiers that they will be absolved of all sins should they die in Ukraine. Orthodox private military companies have also reportedly been established to fight against Ukraine.

Wagner Group Reportedly Resumes Recruitment as Rosgvardia Unit Led by Prigozhin's Son

November 01, 2023  |  Meduza

The report claims that the Wagner group under Yevgeny Prigozhin's son, Pavel Prigozhin, has resumed the recruitment of mercenaries into a unit of the Russian National Guard. The Wagner group has reportedly been incorporated into Rosgvardia, the Russian National Guard.

UK Steps Up Efforts to Counter Mercenary Threats

November 01, 2023  |  OCCRP

The United Kingdom is intensifying its efforts to counter threats from PMCs, notably the Wagner Group associated with the late Russian oligarch Yevgeny Prigozhin, and is establishing a cross-government taskforce that will collaborate with international partners. The Foreign Commonwealth, and Development Office (FCDO) endorsed the idea of a task force on Wagner committed additional resources to counter Wagner and Russian proxy PMCs. They also emphasized using international networks and strategic communications channels to expose Wagner's human rights violations and destabilizing influence.

Contacts

Cortney Weinbaum

weinbaum@rand.org

Senior Management Scientist

Melissa Shostak

mshostak@rand.org

Research Assistant

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis.

Privacy statement | Manage your subscription

Unsubscribe

RAND Corporation

RAND Corporation. 1776 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401-3208.
RAND® is a registered trademark.