In Focus: Private Military Contractors

Prepared by the RAND Corporation | April 2021

Members of the Wagner Group pose for a photo circa 2018 in Syria.  Photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine.

Members of the Wagner Group in Syria circa 2018
(photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine)

This newsletter captures a selection of open source material on malign activities by Private Military Contractors (PMCs). The International Committee of the Red Cross defines PMCs as private businesses providing military and security services. These services include armed guarding, maintenance and operation of weapons systems, prisoner detention, and advice or training to local forces or security personnel. In the context of this newsletter, malign activities are those activities undertaken by a PMC which are illegal, destabilizing, or escalatory. The RAND Corporation gathers this open source material with the support of U.S. government foreign assistance funding.

Africa (sub-Sahara)  |  East Asia and the Pacific  |  Europe and Eurasia  |  Near East (North Africa and the Middle East)

Africa (sub-Sahara)

"What I Saw Is Death": War Crimes in Mozambique's Forgotten Cape

March 01, 2021  |  Amnesty International

The report, written by Amnesty International, describes war crimes committed by the terrorist group Al-Shabaab, the government of Mozambique and the private military and security company Dyck Advisory Group (DAG) in the Cabo Delgado region of Mozambique. According to 53 witnesses, DAG operatives have fired machine guns from helicopters and dropped hand grenades into crowds of people, failing to differentiate between civilian and military targets. DAG is also accused of firing at civilian infrastructure, including hospitals, schools, and houses. Furthermore, the elderly have been disproportionately affected by the war crimes, leading to high rates of injury and death, as they are unable to escape from areas with active fighting or avoid helicopter fire.

Russia's Wagner Group Reportedly Deployed in Africa

March 05, 2021  |  Yeni Safak

Although Moscow does not officially recognize its activities, Wagner - a private military company - is reportedly operating under different names and structures, such as companies related to gold and diamond mining, military training, and cyber warfare. The Wagner Group has been reported as active in Sudan, the Central African Republic (CAR), Libya, Zimbabwe, Angola, Madagascar, Guinea, Guinea Bissau, Mozambique, and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). Furthermore, affiliates of Wagner Group were likely to have been deployed in Libya, South Africa, Sudan, and Mozambique to train local armies, protect high-level figures, fight rebel and terror groups, and protect various resources, including diamonds, gold, and uranium. In exchange for these services, the Wagner offshoots were reportedly granted exclusive privileges and licenses to procure weapons, technology, and military services and use minerals and natural resources in these companies. The article is published in Yeni Safak, a conservative, Turkish pro-Erdogan newspaper.

Russia's Wagner Group's Presence in Africa Goes Beyond Libya

March 04, 2021  |  Daily Sabah

While the Wagner Group's presence in both Libya and Syria has been widely covered, the Wagner Group is also active in other countries in Africa. Some of the African countries that reportedly have a Wagner presence are Sudan, the Central African Republic (CAR), Zimbabwe, Angola, Madagascar, Guinea, Guinea Bissau, Mozambique, and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). It is reported that Wagner and its affiliated companies have some privileges and rights in these countries to use and benefit from the natural resources of these countries and supply arms, technology, and military services in return. Increased PMC activity is part of Russia's larger geostrategic vision in Africa, which includes plans to build bases in six African countries and maintain its position as a major arms supplier. The article is published in Daily Sabah, a conservative, pro-Erdogan newspaper published in Turkey.

Mozambique Looks to Private Sector in War against Islamists

March 15, 2021  |  Financial Times

The government of Mozambique is relying on South African PMC Dyck Advisory Group (DAG) in its fights against Islamists in the northern region of Cabo Delgado despite accusations that DAG has committed war crimes within the region. Starting in 2020, DAG has provided helicopter support to the government of Mozambique. In recent months, the conflict has flared up, leaving hundreds of thousands of people homeless and many more under the threat of famine. The government of Mozambique originally engaged the Russian Wagner Group, whose approximately 100 soldiers were quickly defeated by insurgents. Paramount Group, the South African defense and aerospace group, reportedly has a contract to provide vehicles and training to the army of Mozambique. Burnham Global, a Dubai-based contractor staffed by British military veterans announced last month that Paramount had acquired a stake in the company and that together they had a multi-million-dollar contract with an African government. Burnham Global declined to comment on whether the client was Mozambique.

Russia's Return to Africa

March 09, 2021  |  The International Affairs Review

Russia's announcement that it plans to open a naval base in Sudan marks a clear return of Russia to the African continent amid a push to expand its power. Since the mid-2010s, Russia has sought to reassert itself via a mix of having an official state presence on the continent and the use of private military contractors (PMCs). The most infamous PMC involved in Africa is the Wagner Group, which has close ties to the Kremlin. Besides the Central African Republic (CAR), the Wagner Group is present in Sudan, Libya, Mozambique, and Madagascar. It provides a variety of services like training and supporting local forces, protecting Russian business interests, and interfering in politics by running illegal polling operations.

South African Company to Investigate after Amnesty Says It Shot at Civilians in Mozambique

March 02, 2021  |  Reuters

South African PMC Dyck Advisory Group will hire outside lawyers to look into its activities in Mozambique, it said, after Amnesty International accused it of firing indiscriminately on civilians while helping the government fight an insurgency. The government of Mozambique hired Dyck Advisory Group to help it fight the Ahlu Sunnah Wa-Jama insurgents, known locally as Al-Shabaab, who have declared their allegiance to the Islamic State. Lionel Dyck, the founder of the company, told Reuters that the group took the allegations seriously and would put together an independent legal team in Mozambique to conduct a board of inquiry into activities in the country.

East Asia and the Pacific

Who Guards the 'Maritime Silk Road'?

June 24, 2020  |  War on the Rocks

China is using domestic private security companies (PSCs) to protect the Maritime Silk Road, which centers around port construction, international shipping, and ocean governance, and is part of the Belt and Road Initiative. The Maritime Silk Road primarily focuses on sea lanes of communication across the Mediterranean Sea, Indian Ocean, and Pacific Ocean. By using PSCs to secure the Maritime Silk Road rather than the People's Liberation Army Navy (PLAN), China hopes to emphasize the economic nature of the Belt and Road Initiative and deflect scrutiny away from the PLAN. Chinese PSCs active in protecting the Maritime Silk Road include Hua Xin Security Services, Zhongjun Junhong Secuirty Group "Sea Guards", Hanwei International Security Services, China Security Technology Group, and DeWe Security Group. Chinese PSCs provide both armed and unarmed escort services for merchant ships and fishing vessels traveling along the Maritime Silk Road. Despite the expansion and state support of PSCs, many Chinese PSCs either operate in legal gray areas or provide illegal services. In particular, Chinese law prevents PSCs from using firearms abroad, but many PSCs provide armed maritime escort services, either through gaining permission from the Chinese government or illegally operating with arms.

Europe and Eurasia

Russian Mercenaries in the Great-Power Competition: Strategic Supermen or Weak Link?

March 09, 2021  |  RAND Blog

Russia has increasingly relied on private security contractors, which have many of the characteristics of mercenaries, to maintain a Russia-favorable global status quo and to undermine its competitors' interests. This reliance on mercenaries stems from Russia's inability to project ground power outside of its near abroad due to both its limited logistics infrastructure and heavy reliance on conscripts. As a result, Russia has relied on employing heavily armed mercenaries from the Wagner Group and other PMCs friendly with or run by the government. Russia has outsourced its foreign policy in Libya, Syria, the Central African Republic, Madagascar, Mozambique, Sudan, Ukraine, Yemen, Burundi, and other global hot spots to these mercenaries. While public narratives have focused on portraying Russian mercenaries as elite gray-zone warriors that allow Russia to beat the United States and NATO in great-power competition, Russia's use of mercenaries actually highlights Russian weaknesses, including low will to fight and flaws in state power. Furthermore, Russian mercenaries have performed poorly abroad, with notable defeats in Syria, Mozambique, and Libya. Many Russian mercenaries have little to no training or experience in combat, and PMCs remain illegal in Russia, limiting the amount of government support provided to them while maintaining plausible deniability for the Russian government.

What Laws Constrain This Russian Private Military Company?

March 23, 2021  |  Lawfare

Though Wagner's activities are nominally regulated by both international law and the domestic laws of the countries where the group is present, these laws put relatively few constraints on Wagner's operations. While Wagner Group is a private military and security cooperation, it is different from most private military and security companies in that Wagner employees often engage in combat operations and that it has a close relationship with the Russian government, which actively helps Wagner secure its contracts. Since its conception in 2014, Wagner has been active in Ukraine, Syria, Libya, Armenia, Azerbaijan, the Central African Republic (CAR), Madagascar, Mozambique, Rwanda, and Sudan. Wagner is subjected to a range of laws and conventions related to mercenarism, including national laws in the different countries regulating mercenaries; the International Convention against the Recruitment, Use, Financing and Training of Mercenaries (ICRUFTM); the Additional Protocol (I) to the Geneva Conventions; and the Organization of African Unity Convention for the Elimination of Mercenarism in Africa (OAU CEM). Of the countries in which Wagner is active, only Azerbaijan, Mozambique, and Ukraine have created laws criminalizing mercenarism. In addition to laws and conventions regulating the use of mercenaries, Wagner Group members could also be subject to any national laws such as those that punish killing, torture, and terrorism if employees committed these actions. If Wagner Group employees were to commit serious violations of international humanitarian law on the territory of any states parties to the Rome Statute or against the citizens of any states parties, the employees responsible for the acts could be prosecuted by the International Criminal Court for violating Article 8 of the Rome Statue, which punishes grave breaches of the Geneva Conventions. However, only CAR, Madagascar, and Ukraine have ratified the Rome Statute. Moreover, even countries that would allow for the prosecution of mercenary activity are unlikely to do so as prosecutions of mercenaries by state authorities are rarely attempted or carried out.

Near East (North Africa and the Middle East)

Russian Mercenaries Refuse to Depart Libyan Soil

March 11, 2021  |  Libyan Express

Although the deadline for their departure has passed, Russia's Wagner mercenary group, estimated at 2,000, continue to operate on Libyan soil, backed by Russian fighter planes. The Russian Wagner Group operatives are centralized in eastern and southern Libya, supporting the forces of Field Marshall Khalifa Haftar. Following the arrival of a small UN Security Council team, the Wagner Group withdrew some of its forces from Site and Jufra following the ceasefire zone to appear as though they have withdrawn from the region.

Libyan Officials Call on West to Assist in Ousting Russian Forces

February 19, 2021  |  Daily Sabah

The Libyan Government of National Accord has called on the United States and its Western allies to assist in ousting all Russian forces, including Wagner Group, from the country. GNA Defense Minister Salah Eddine al-Namrush stated that Russian influence is expanding beyond military occupation into the realms of political and media meddling, threatening planned elections in Libya. Libyan Presidential Council member Mohammed Ammari stated that the Wagner Group would most likely not abide by any agreement to withdraw from Libya and that Russian expansion in Libya was a threat to both Europe and America. The article is published in Daily Sabah, a conservative, pro-Erdogan newspaper published in Turkey.

Grisly Killing in Syria Spawns Legal Case against Russian Mercenaries

March 15, 2021  |  The New York Times

On March 15, 2021, three human rights groups announced a legal action that they say is the first to target soldiers from the Russian mercenary organization Wagner for crimes committed in Syria, highlighting growing efforts to hold accountable contract soldiers in war zones. The case revolves around a video showing Russian Wagner contractors killing a man who they claimed was a member of the Islamic State militant group. The video shows a group of Russian-speaking men in the ruined Al Shaer gas plant in the city of Homs beating their victim with a sledgehammer then dismembering and burning the body. The International Federation for Human Rights and two other organizations - the civil rights society Memorial and the Syrian Center for Media and Freedom of Expression - plan to file the court case in the European Court of Human Rights, whose rulings Russia is bound by treaty to observe. Before the case can be heard in the European Court of Human Rights, legal activities in Russia must be exhausted.

Wagner Mercenaries Continue Digging Trenches between Sirte and Jufra

March 10, 2021  |  The Libyan Observer

The media office of the Volcano of Rage Operation, which is associated with the Libyan Government of National Accord, obtained new photos of Russian Wagner Group Mercenaries and Haftar forces digging trenches between Sirte and Jufra. It stated that the digging could be for oil pipelines within the trenches which could be part of oil concessions made by Haftar to Wagner mercenaries. Wagner Group and Sudanese Janjaweed mercenaries control the Sharara oil field.

Russian Wagner Mercenaries Refuse to Leave Libya

March 10, 2021  |  Middle Eastern Monitor

Although they were expected to leave Libya last month, the Wagner mercenaries, estimated at about 2,000, continue to operate in eastern and southern Libya backed by fighter planes sent by Russia. Wagner withdrew some of its forces from Sirte and Jufra to adjacent areas following internal and local pressure to appear as though it had pulled out of the region before it became clear that those mercenaries were still tightening their control over the area. It is believed the presence of international peacekeepers in Sirte and Jufra will push the Wagner mercenaries to withdraw completely from the region unless Russia resorts to blocking the dispatch of these forces through the UN Security Council.

At the Mercy of Foreign Powers

February 27, 2021  |  The Washington Post

At least 20,000 foreign mercenaries from Russia, Syria, Chad, Turkey, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), and Sudan have been funneled into Libya to participate in the country's civil war. Most of the fighters are funded by Russia, Turkey, and the UAE and provide support to both sides of the conflict. Furthermore, the parties have ignored a recent deadline to remove foreign forces as part of a UN-led attempt to broker a deal to end the conflict. Russia and Turkey, the two dominant players in Libya, are vying for shares of Libyan oil and natural gas, long-term access to military bases, and influence over the shape of any future government. Nearly all of the Russian fighters in Libya are contractors with the Wagner Group. Russia, through its use of the Wagner Group, has supported the Khalifa Haftar and the Libyan National Army, based out of eastern Libya. Turkey has provided support to the Government of National Accord (GNA) which is based out of Tripoli.

UN Envoy Demands Foreign Fighters and Mercenaries Exit Libya

March 24, 2021  |  The Washington Post

On Wednesday, March 24, the new UN special envoy for Libya urged foreign forces and mercenaries to leave the country as demanded in last year's cease-fire agreement. A recently released report by the UN experts accused Turkey and Qatar of backing forces loyal to the UN-supported administration in Tripoli, in the west, while the United Arab Emirates, Russia, and Egypt have supported Khalifa Haftar, the military commander controlling the eastern and southern parts of Libya. The report documented dozens of arms shipments and the deployment of mercenaries - Russians, Syrians, Sudanese, Chadians, and others - brought to Libya to bolster its warring sides.

Contacts

John V. Parachini

johnvp@rand.org

Senior International and Defense Researcher

Melissa Shostak

mshostak@rand.org

Research Assistant

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis.

Privacy statement | Manage your subscription

Unsubscribe

RAND Corporation

RAND Corporation. 1776 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401-3208.
RAND® is a registered trademark.