In Focus: Private Military Contractors

Prepared by the RAND Corporation | April 2021

Members of the Wagner Group pose for a photo circa 2018 in Syria.  Photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine.

Members of the Wagner Group in Syria circa 2018
(photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine)

This newsletter captures a selection of open source material on malign activities by Private Military Contractors (PMCs). The International Committee of the Red Cross defines PMCs as private businesses providing military and security services. These services include armed guarding, maintenance and operation of weapons systems, prisoner detention, and advice or training to local forces or security personnel. In the context of this newsletter, malign activities are those activities undertaken by a PMC which are illegal, destabilizing, or escalatory. The RAND Corporation gathers this open source material with the support of U.S. government foreign assistance funding.

Africa (sub-Sahara)  |  East Asia and the Pacific  |  Europe and Eurasia  |  Near East (North Africa and the Middle East)

Africa (sub-Sahara)

Back from Mozambique, Mercenary Sees "Only Hardships" for Insurgent-Hit North

April 21, 2021  |  France 24

Dyck Advisory Group's (DAG) counter-insurgency in Mozambique ended on April 6, less than two weeks after rebels staged an attack on Palma in northern Mozambique. Speaking to Agence France-Presse from his home in South Africa, Lionel Dyck, a retired colonel of the Zimbabwean army, expressed concern at the security vacuum created by DAG's departure from Mozambique. Dyck stated that "the gap with nobody there is the most dangerous period Mozambique has ever had," noting that soldiers were both under-trained and poorly equipped. DAG was contracted to provide air support to foot soldiers, sending in helicopters from Pemba, the provincial capital of Cabo Delgado, when attacks were reported. He claimed that the Mozambican army's Mi-24 helicopters were not suited to guerilla warfare because they did not turn swiftly enough. Dyck declined to comment on a recent Amnesty International report accusing his mercenaries of indiscriminately firing into crowds, resulting in hundreds of civilian deaths.

Insurgency Threatens Mozambique's Historic Natural Gas Investment Boom

April 15, 2021  |  CNBC

In late March, an armed Islamist group known as Al-Shabab attacked the gas-rich town of Palma in Mozambique's northern Cabo Delgado province, inflicting mass civilian casualties and displacing tens of thousands. The attack came within hours of French energy giant Total announcing that it was resuming operations at its Mozambique Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) project, a $20 billion facility under construction in the nearby Afungi Peninsula. Both Mozambican security forces and private military contractors, along with Total's security team, were blindsided by the raid by Al-Shabab. The ensuing battle lasted around 12 days.

An Overview of Foreign Security Involvement in Mozambique

April 07, 2021  |  DefenceWeb

A number of private security companies, foreign governments, and militaries have become involved in Mozambique in its fight against the insurgency in Cabo Delgado, but the Mozambican government has so far largely limited external involvement. Russian security company Wagner Group, which has close ties to Moscow, was hired by the Mozambican government to address the insurgency in Cabo Delgado alongside government forces, but the estimated 200 Wagner personnel left Mozambique in November 2019 after suffering heavy casualties. They were replace by the Dyck Advisory Group (DAG) which provided aerial support to the armed forces of Mozambique. DAG's three month contract with the Mozambican police was extended in July 2020, and was reported to have ended on April 6, 2021. At the end of September 2020, Frontier Services Group (FSG), which is tied to Erik Prince, terminated its joint venture with Mozambique's national oil company Empresa Nacional de Hidrocarbonetos (ENH). Beyond the joint venture with ENH, FSG also registered two other companies in Mozambique, Blue-Fin Lda and FSG Mozambique Segurança Lda, which is believed to have taken possession of the fleet of maritime patrol vessels that were at the center of inflated construction contracts funded by international loans that precipitate Mozambique's 2017 sovereign default. FSG Mozambique was hired in March or April 2020 and appears to still be active. Total, the French company developing liquid natural gas (LNG) fields in northern Mozambique, may have contracts with security companies. Private security companies in the region include Arkhe, a subsidiary of South African private security company Omega Risk Solutions; Blue Mountain Group, a Welsh private security company; G4S, a Mozambican private security company; and Gardaworld, a Canadian private security company.

Foreign Involvement Growing in Mozambique Counterinsurgency

April 06, 2021  |  Council on Foreign Relations

Jihadi attacks in Mozambique's Cabo Delgado province are accelerating, with heavy fighting breaking out around the town of Palma. In response, South Africa's President Cyril Ramaphosa sent South African troops to evacuate South African nationals. The French oil and gas company Total has evacuated its employees from its Afungi gas facility and suspended construction on a $20 billion project. Mozambique has requested military assistance from South Africa, but South Africa declined on the basis that the insurgency is too big for a bilateral response. Meanwhile, the contract with South African private military contractor Dyck Advisory Group will not be renewed. Mozambique has largely denied international help throughout most of the insurgency.

U.N. Experts Alarmed by Russian Security Contractors' "Abuses" in Central Africa

March 31, 2021  |  Reuters

United Nations experts have expressed alarm over reports of "grave human rights abuses" by Russian mercenaries in the Central African Republic, where they have supported the embattled government's military. The alleged abuses identified by the U.N. include mass summary executions, arbitrary detentions, torture, forced disappearances, forced displacement of civilians, indiscriminate targeting of civilian facilities, and attacks on humanitarian workers. The U.N. listed the Wagner Group as one of the Russian companies involved in potential human rights violations. The U.N. also raised concerns regarding the close proximity of Russian contractors to the U.N.'s MINUSCA peacekeeping operation, which has more than 13,000 uniformed personnel in the Central African Republic

Mercenaries Fighting Insurgents in Mozambique Set to Exit

March 31, 2021  |  Bloomberg

The Dyck Advisory Group (DAG), which has been providing aerial support to Mozambican ground forces battling Islamic State-linked insurgents near a $20 billion natural gas project, is set to leave Mozambique by April 2. According to Lionel Dyck, the head of DAG, the group's one year agreement has not been extended. The end of DAG's contract coincides with an insurgency operation which threatens Palma, the closest town to the Total SE natural gas investment site in northern Mozambique. DAG has come under criticism for its involvement in the war and was called out by Amnesty International for potential human rights violations.

SA Military Company in Insurgent Combat Zone, the Dyck Advisory Group, Will Not Extend Contract with Mozambique

March 31, 2021  |  Daily Maverick

South African PMC Dyck Advisory Group (DAG) did not have its contract for providing security services to the government of Mozambique renewed. This news follows a report from Amnesty International which accused DAG of indiscriminately shooting civilians while pursuing insurgents. One source stated that DAG's last helicopter sortie would be Friday, April 2, while another source stated that DAG and the government of Mozambique were continuing to negotiate regarding the continued presence of DAG in Mozambique. The news follows an insurgency by Islamic State-linked terrorists in the northern Mozamibcan town of Palma. Recently, the government of Mozambique appears to be replacing DAG with larger Russian-made Mi-17 and Mi-24 helicopters piloted by Mozambicans and Ukrainians as well as Gazelle light helicopters, the type of helicopters used by DAG, supplied by South African arms company Paramount and piloted by Mozambicans trained by Paramount at its flight school in Polokwane.

East Asia and the Pacific

Is China About to Deploy Private Military Companies in Central Asia?

March 25, 2021  |  Jamestown Foundation

Russian experts are concerned that Chinese private military companies may appear in Kyrgyzstan, creating problems for Moscow which has a military base in Kyrgyzstan. According to Stanislav Pritchin, a senior researcher at the Moscow Center for Post-Soviet Research in the Russian Academy of Sciences, political instability in Kyrgyzstan represents a threat to Chinese investments within the country, and the current anti-Chinese rhetoric within Kyrgyzstan increases the likelihood that China will interfere. China has previously been cautious in using its private military companies abroad, refraining from sending private military companies to Turkmenistan during a period of unrest in 2015 and 2016. When Chinese private military companies have been deployed to African companies, they were limited to defending buildings rather than influencing politics within the countries where they were hosted.

Europe and Eurasia

The U.S. Military Must Plan for Encounters with Private Military Companies

March 30, 2021  |  Brookings Institute

Russia has increasingly used private military companies (PMCs) such as the Wagner Group and others over the past decade to advance its strategic interests in places where official Russian government intervention is perceived to be too costly. PMC "proxy" forces allow the Russian government and affiliated Russian oligarchs to expand their influence and financial gain in developing countries while avoiding attribution through continuous use of disinformation, deception, and propaganda. Russian PMCs became prominent in 2014 in Ukraine, and have become increasingly prevalent in the Middle East, Africa, and Latin America. The Wagner PMC is led by the oligarch Evgenii Prigozhin, who is deeply connected to President Vladimir Putin, allowing Prigozhin to interlace his company's financial investments with those of the Russian state. Russia has greatly stepped up the use of PMCs as proxies to protect its interests around the world during the past decade, with Russian PMC presence doubling between 2015 and 2020, based on open-source reporting.

Two Alleged Mercenaries from Syria to Stand Trial in Armenia

March 30, 2021  |  OC Media (Open Caucasus)

Armenian police have completed their investigation into two men captured during the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War who are accused of being mercenaries from Syria. If the findings are approved by the prosecutor's office, the men will stand trial in Armenia and face a slate of criminal charges, including terrorism. Armenia claimed it captured the two in November. According to investigations by Reuters and the BBC, as well as Russian and French authorities, the Turkish government recruited hundreds of fighters in Syria who were then deployed to Nagorno-Karabakh as combatants on the Azerbaijani side. Both Azerbaijani and Turkish authorities have denied that they deployed mercenaries during the fighting.

"Illegal PMC" Exposed in Ukraine, SBU Says

March 24, 2021  |  UNIAN

The Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) says its operatives have exposed and terminated the activity of an illegal armed group or private military company (PMC). The SBU stated that "the group consisted over 150 people and operated under the guise of security firms and NGOs." Members of the PMC, known as NABU, received training in Kyiv and abroad. The SBU also claimed that the PMC was connected to former People's Deputy Semen Semenchenko and Yevhan Shevchenko. Furthermore, the SBU alleges that Semenchenko and Shevchenko organized the import from Russia of spare military equipment parts which were then sold at inflated prices to state-owned defense firms.

Near East (North Africa and the Middle East)

Russia's Wagner Pressures Libya's Southern Tribes to Support Haftar

April 16, 2021  |  Daily Sabah

Russia's Wagner Group is increasingly pressuring tribes in Libya's south that currently support the Government of National Accord (GNA) to support General Khalifa Haftar. Sources in Libya told the Daily Sabah that Wagner Group is threatening to send forces into the tribes' territories under the cover of fighting the Daesh terrorist group if the tribes do not provide support to Haftar. Sources recently stated that the Wagner Group is preparing to send 300 Syrian fighters to fight alongside Haftar in Libya. The Daily Sabah is a conservative, pro-Erdogan newspaper published in Turkey.

Russian Wagner Group to Send 300 Syrian Fighters to Libya

April 12, 2021  |  Daily Sabah

Russia's Wagner Group is preparing to send 300 Syrian fighters from Deir el-Zour, Syria, to fight alongside General Khalifa Haftar. Sources told the Daily Sasbah that the new Syrian mercenary group is comprised of fighters loyal to the regime, Iran-backed foreign groups, and volunteer's from Bashar Assad's army. The group is currently receiving training in Syria and will be sent to Benghazi in eastern Libya toward the end of April. The Daily Sabah is a conservative, pro-Erdogan newspaper published in Turkey.

Normalisation between Egypt and Turkey Hindered by Issues of Mercenaries, Brotherhood

April 10, 2021  |  The Arab Weekly

Egyptian security forces told The Arab Weekly that talks to normalize relations between Cairo and Ankara have slowed down, with Cairo having doubts about Turkey's serious intent to withdraw its mercenaries from Libya and the extradition of Muslim Brotherhood leaders wanted by the Egyptian judiciary. Recent developments have contradicted accounts which circulated last week that reconciliation between the two sides was imminent. While Cairo was waiting for Turkey to withdraw its Syrian mercenaries from western Libya, the Turkish government recently sent a new batch of 380 fighters.

Exclusive: Satellite Images Reveal How Shadowy Wagner Group Has Become Vladimir Putin's "Private Army"

April 07, 2021  |  The Telegraph

Declassified images, thought to come from U.S. spy satellites, show Russia is supplying tanks and planes to the Wagner Group in Libya. The images show the Wagner Group using regular Russian military equipment in Libya, suggesting it is, in effect, a deniable part of the Kremlin's army. The Wagner Group is particularly active in Syria, Libya, and across sub-Saharan Africa, where armed assistance is rewarded with access to energy reserves, gold, and other precious metals. The images show Russian Pantsir air defense systems (NATO reporting name SA-22), Il-76 military cargo aircraft, and mine resistant armored vehicles being operated in Libya. According to security experts, Russia has turned to private military companies for fighting in foreign conflicts in order to avoid negative domestic press. Images of Soviet casualties returning from Afghanistan undermined confidence in the Soviet Union and contributed to its eventual collapse. Ties between private military companies and the Russian government are hazy, but catering oligarch Evgeny Prigozhin, often referred to as Putin's Chef, is thought to sponsor the Wagner Group and serve as a link between the Kremlin and Russian mercenaries.

Contacts

John V. Parachini

johnvp@rand.org

Senior International and Defense Researcher

Melissa Shostak

mshostak@rand.org

Research Assistant

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis.

Privacy statement | Manage your subscription

Unsubscribe

RAND Corporation

RAND Corporation. 1776 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401-3208.
RAND® is a registered trademark.