In Focus: Private Military and Security Companies

Prepared by the RAND Corporation | April 2022

Members of the Wagner Group pose for a photo circa 2018 in Syria.  Photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine.

Members of the Wagner Group in Syria circa 2018
(photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine)

This newsletter captures a selection of open-source material on Private Military and Security Companies (PMSCs) during March 2022. The United Nations defines PMSC as a corporate entity which provides on a compensatory basis military and/or security services by physical persons and/or legal entities. Military services include specialized services related to military actions, including strategic planning, intelligence, investigation, land, sea or air reconnaissance, flight operations of any type, manned or unmanned, satellite surveillance, any kind of knowledge transfer with military applications, material and technical support to armed forces and other related activities. Security services include armed guarding or protection of buildings, installations, property and people, any kind of knowledge transfer with security and policing applications, development and implementation of informational security measures and other related activities. In the context of this newsletter, malign activities are those activities undertaken by a PMSC which are illegal, destabilizing, or escalatory. The RAND Corporation seeks credible open-source material and curates but does not verify the content of the open-source material in this monthly summary with the support of U.S. government foreign assistance funding to raise awareness of the activities of PMSCs.

Africa (sub-Sahara)  |  East Asia and the Pacific  |  Europe and Eurasia

Africa (sub-Sahara)

Security, Soft Power and Regime Support: Spheres of Russian Influence in Africa

March 23, 2022  |  Tony Blair Institute for Global Change

As conflict in Africa accelerates at an unprecedented rate, African governments are struggling to combat insurgencies in addition to their other urgent priorities. This is compelling some leaders to call for external security support in the form of PMCs and mercenaries. Turkish PMC Sadat is supporting state militaries in Ethiopia, Libya, Somalia, Sudan, and Tunisia, while South Africa's Dyck Advisory Group has previously operated in Mozambique. Russia has deployed PMCs in at least 21 countries since 2014, with the majority on the African continent. Between 2014 and 2018, Russia's PMC activity in Africa more than tripled. In addition, Russia's Wagner operations extend beyond narrow security objectives and are adapting to opportunities that secure more covert influence for the country, such as providing political strategists to embattled regimes, interfering in elections, and gaining natural resource concessions for Russia.

Sudan's Foreign Ministry Denies Presence of Russian Wagner Group

March 22, 2022  |  Reuters

Sudan's foreign ministry on March 22 denied the presence of Russian PMC Wagner Group in the country, in response to a statement by Western diplomats. Representatives of the United States, United Kingdom and Norway wrote in a piece published in a Sudanese newspaper on March 21 that the Wagner Group "spreads disinformation on social media and engages in illicit activities connected to gold mining" in Sudan. In 2020, the United States sanctioned M-Invest and its subsidiary Meroe Gold which it said were controlled by Prigozhin and operating in Sudan.

The Wagner Group's Playbook in Africa: Mali

March 18, 2022  |  FPRI

The Wagner Group has pursued the same playbook in Mali that it previously executed in Sudan and the Central African Republic (CAR). This strategy is based on Wagner's response to African governments' requests for security assistance, particularly when African leaders feel that Western states have not done enough to help them via security cooperation, military sales, or through anti-terrorism operations. First, Wagner conducts disinformation and pro-government information warfare strategies. Second, Wagner secures payment for its services through concessions in extractive industries, particularly precious metal mining operations. Finally, Wagner becomes involved with the country's military, launching a relationship directly with Russia's military, usually through training, advising, personal security, and anti-insurgency operations.

AFRICOM's Chief Warned Mali about the Wagner Group. It Didn't Work

March 17, 2022  |  Defense News

U.S. General Stephen Townsend, commander of U.S. Africa Command, personally urged Mali's ruling military junta not to invite in Russian Wagner Group mercenaries before the country invited them in. Mali reportedly allowed in as many as 1,000 mercenaries from the Wagner Group since December, highlighting competing efforts by Russia and the U.S. to wield influence in the region. General Townsend stated at a House Armed Service Committee hearing on March 24 that Mali's transitional government invited Wagner because it thought it would do a better job than the French against violent extremist groups plaguing the country. General Townsend stated that the president of Mali stated that he was dealing only with Russia's Ministry of Defense, conflicting statements by Vladimir Putin that the Russian state has nothing to do with Russian military contractors in Mali.

Mass Grave in Niono: MINUSMA Accuses Malian Army and Wagner Group

March 15, 2022  |  The Africa Report

A report by the human rights division of MINUSMA, the UN's peacekeeping mission in Mali, suggests the involvement of the Malian army and mercenaries from the Russian Wagner Group in the massacre of some thirty people in early March 2022. The Malian Armed Forces denounced MINUSMA's charge as a "disinformation" operation, arguing that they "could not be responsible for such an abjection." On March 2, at least thirty charred bodies were found near the village of Dangere-Wotoro, in the commune of Dogofry, Niono Cercle, an administrative subdivision of Mali's Ségou region. According to the document, the remains found near Dengere-Wotoro included those of children, and the report suggests that "the victims were doused with gasoline and burned alive." The report also indicates that investigations are continuing into other cases of "serious violations" committed in the Niono Cercle.

Russia Ramps Up Ties with Sudan as Ukraine War Rages

March 11, 2022  |  France 24

As much of the West seeks to isolate Russia after its invasion of Ukraine, experts say Moscow is boosting relations with its longtime African ally Sudan, eyeing its gold wealth and strategic location. Sudanese paramilitary commander Mohamed Hamdan Daglo visited Moscow on February 23, the day before Russia's invasion to Ukraine, most likely to discuss arrangements between his forces and Russian security apparatuses with links in Sudan and Africa, especially Wagner Group. M-Invest, a Russian mining company linked to Wagner owner Evgenii Prigozhin, has also been mining gold in Sudan since 2017.

Russian Mercenaries Have Landed in West Africa Pushing Putin's Goals as Kremlin Is Increasingly Isolated

March 09, 2022  |  The Washington Post

Hundreds of Russian Wagner Group mercenaries have entered into Mali since December 2021. Mali's military junta has denied hiring Wagner, saying they work only with army instructors from Russia. In February, Putin stated that Russia was only involved in "commercial activities" in Africa, saying the Kremlin has "nothing to do with the companies working in Mali." Since the mercenaries began appearing in December 2021, new government rules have required Mali's military partners to avoid areas where Russians are deployed. Between 800 and 1,000 mercenaries are now working in Mali.

East Asia and the Pacific

China's Security Contractors Have Avoided the Fate of Russia's Military Contractors, So Far

March 11, 2022  |  Real Clear Defense

China's approach to private security contractors (PSCs) is much more limited in scope and effects than Russia's use of private military contractors (PMCs). Indicators suggest that Chinese planners see benefits in expanding and maturing the country's use of private contractors, which creates the potential for dangerous results for China and the rest of the world. If China is progressing towards a more militarized approach for its overseas contractors, the government may follow a roadmap that is similar to that it has used in other sectors and may encounter pitfalls similar to those encountered by other nations' PMCs.

Europe and Eurasia

At Least 1,300 Wagner Mercenaries Sent from Libya to Help Russian Forces in Ukraine

March 25, 2022  |  Yeni Safak

Some 1,300 mercenaries of the Russian private military contractor Wagner Group have been moved from Libya to Ukraine to fight alongside Russian forces, according to a Libyan security analyst. Adel Abdel-Kafi, a military a security expert, stated that there were 2,200 Wagner militants in Libya prior to the removal of these mercenaries. Adbel-Kafi said the Wagner Group is increasingly relying on fighters from African nations and continues to recruit people from Mali, Chad and Sudan. Yeni Safak is a Turkish newspaper with ties to Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and the Turkish government.

UK Sanctions Dozens More Russians Including Wagner Mercenary Group, Abramovich Ally

March 24, 2022  |  The Times of Israel

The UK has sanctioned 59 more Russian individuals and entities, including the Wagner Group, as well as six Belarusian enterprises over Moscow's invasion of Ukraine. The Wagner Group has reportedly been tasked with assassinating Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and has faced multiple accusations of carrying out crimes and atrocities around the world.

Ukraine War: Why Is Russia Encouraging Foreign Fighters to Join?

March 23, 2022  |  Al Jazeera

Russia is looking to recruit fighters from Syria to fight in Ukraine. In addition to employing the regular Russian army in Ukraine, intelligence officials in Kyiv say Moscow is using members of the Wagner Group. Fighters from Chechnya are also battling Ukrainian forces. According to Cristian Nitoiu, a lecturer in diplomacy and international governance at Loughborough University London, Wagner Group mercenaries would have better training in urban and guerrilla warfare than the Russian conventional army. Nitoiu also notes that the loss of mercenary fighters can be less damaging for Putin's regime as news or images of dead Russian soldiers in Ukraine can affect the popularity of the regime.

Russia Sends Military Contractors from Georgia Breakaway Region to Ukraine

March 18, 2022  |  Atlantic Council

Former South Ossetia President Eduard Kokoity confirmed that a contingent of private military contractors, who are residents of South Ossetia and served with the 4th Guards Military Base of the Russian Armed Forces, were traveling to Ukraine to "finish off the Nazis." Video footage circulated on social media showing the movement of military equipment in South Ossetia.

Moscow Turns U.S. Volunteers Into New Bogeyman in Ukraine

March 15, 2022  |  Foreign Policy

As scrutiny of Russia's increasing reliance on mercenaries in Ukraine mounts, the Kremlin is trying to deflect it back onto U.S. veterans who have volunteered to defend Ukraine. From the outset of the invasion, reports have indicated that the Wagner Group has been called up to bolster Russia's regular and conscript forces. By targeting foreign fighters, Moscow may be trying to create a boogeyman to blame if it deploys chemical or biological weapons.

Russia Involving Private Security Companies in War with Ukraine - SBU

March 10, 2022  |  UkrInform

According to the Ukrainian State Security Service (SBU), Russia is sending employees of private security companies to fight in Ukraine. One private security guard, who was taken prisoner by the Ukrainian forces, stated that he worked for a security company in Rostov and was hired to deliver cargo, later revealed to be KAMAZ trucks with ammunition to bomb residential areas of Kharkiv.

Ukraine War: Private Russian Mercenaries "Likely Deploying to Fight in Ukraine" to Support Putin's Soldiers, UK's MoD Says

March 10, 2022  |  Sky News

The United Kingdom's Ministry of Defense stated that Russian PMCs are "likely deploying to fight in Ukraine" and that "the Russian state almost certainly maintains extensive links with Russian PMCs, despite repeated denials." On March 8, the Ukrainian military confirmed there had been clashes near Kyiv with members of the Russian PMC Liga, also known as Wagner.

Ministry of Defense of Russia: PMCs Are Being Actively Recruited in the U.S. to Be Sent to Ukraine (Минобороны России: в США активно вербуются сотрудники ЧВК для отправки на Украину)

March 03, 2022  |  TV Zvezda

The official representative of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation Igor Konashenkov stated that the United States is actively recruiting members of PMCs to send to Ukraine. Konashenkov added that foreign mercenaries who have already arrived in Ukraine are raiding Russian convoys of equipment and supplies, attacking aircraft covering them. This article was reported in TV Zvezda, which is run by the Russian Armed Forces.

Contacts

John V. Parachini

johnvp@rand.org

Senior International and Defense Researcher

Melissa Shostak

mshostak@rand.org

Research Assistant

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis.

Privacy statement | Manage your subscription

Unsubscribe

RAND Corporation

RAND Corporation. 1776 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401-3208.
RAND® is a registered trademark.