In Focus: Private Military Contractors

Prepared by the RAND Corporation | May 2022

Members of the Wagner Group pose for a photo circa 2018 in Syria.  Photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine.

Members of the Wagner Group in Syria circa 2018
(photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine)

This newsletter captures a selection of open-source material on Private Military and Security Companies (PMSCs) during March 2022. The United Nations defines PMSC as a corporate entity which provides on a compensatory basis military and/or security services by physical persons and/or legal entities. Military services include specialized services related to military actions, including strategic planning, intelligence, investigation, land, sea or air reconnaissance, flight operations of any type, manned or unmanned, satellite surveillance, any kind of knowledge transfer with military applications, material and technical support to armed forces and other related activities. Security services include armed guarding or protection of buildings, installations, property and people, any kind of knowledge transfer with security and policing applications, development and implementation of informational security measures and other related activities. In the context of this newsletter, malign activities are those activities undertaken by a PMSC which are illegal, destabilizing, or escalatory. The RAND Corporation seeks credible open-source material and curates but does not verify the content of the open-source material in this monthly summary with the support of U.S. government foreign assistance funding to raise awareness of the activities of PMSCs.

Africa (sub-Sahara)  |  Europe and Eurasia  |  Near East (North Africa and the Middle East)

Africa (sub-Sahara)

"White Hands": The Rise of Private Armies in African Conflicts

April 28, 2022  |  Al Jazeera

PMCs provide a range of services in African states including training, logistical support and undertaking combat. They also protect some politicians and their assets or secure private foreign investments like mining sites. PMCs involved in Africa include the Wagner Group, French agency Secopex, British group Aegis Defence Services, South African PMC Dyck Advisory Group, and South African group Specialised Tasks, Training, Equipment and Protection (STTEP). There is an ongoing debate on the effectiveness of foreign mercenaries given their lack of nuanced knowledge of the countries they operate in and the lack of addressing core issues that fuel insurgencies.

Beyond Ukraine: Wagner Group Mercenaries Are Putin's "Coercive Tool" in Africa Too

April 26, 2022  |  The Times of Israel

In sub-Saharan Africa, the Wagner Group has gained substantial footholds for Russia in Central African Republic (CAR), Sudan, and Mali. General Stephen Townsend, the commander of AFRICOM, told a Senate hearing in March that the Wagner Group is essentially running CAR and are a growing force in Mali. Russia's game plan for Africa, where it has applied its influence as far north as Libya and as far south as Mozambique, is to seek alliance with regimes or juntas shunned by the West or facing insurgencies and internal challenges to their rule. The African leaders get recognition from the Kremlin and military muscle from Wagner. The African countries pay for this by giving Russia prime access to oil, gas, gold, diamonds, and valuable minerals. Russia is also using this campaign in Africa to wage an ideological battle, using Wagner as a "coercive tool" to undermine Western ideas of democracy and turn countries toward Moscow.

Mapping Disinformation in Africa

April 26, 2022  |  Africa Center for Strategic Studies

Russia has been the leading purveyor of disinformation campaigns in Africa with at least sixteen known operations on the continent. Russian disinformation campaigns are directed toward a political objective, typically propping an isolated African regime, which is then beholden to Moscow. Yevgeny Prigozhin, a Russian oligarch who leads the Wagner Group, has exported disinformation campaigns to every African country where Wagner has operated. In addition to promoting a favored regime and Russia's role on the continent, the messages of these campaigns are anti-democratic, anti-Western, and anti-UN. Russian success in reaching a large African audience online with little overhead has inspired disinformation campaigns by other foreign governments. Of the more than fifty documented disinformation campaigns on the continent, roughly sixty percent are externally driven, though these figures are inherently imprecise. The article also includes a chart documenting recent disinformation campaigns in Africa.

Russian Mercenaries Staged Atrocities in Mali, France Says

April 26, 2022  |  Foreign Policy

The French military has accused Russian mercenaries in Mali of staging a mass grave using real bodies in an apparent attempt to frame French forces and discredit Paris's counterterrorism operation in the region. Images gathered by an intelligence overflight conducted by the French Armed Forces last week and shared with Foreign Policy show around a dozen white men in combat fatigues - thought to be operatives from the Kremlin-linked Wagner Group - shoveling sand over a pile of bodies partially buried near the site of the former French military base in Gossi. The images were gathered just days after France handed control of the base over to the Malian Armed Forces as part of its military withdrawal from the country, following nearly ten years of counterterrorism operations.

Nigeria's Frosty Interest in Private Military Contractors

April 24, 2022  |  HumAngle

Nigeria appears to have an appetite for foreign military contractors, but agreements with them are often limited to training and equipment support roles. It may be because this approach is associated with less political risk and international scrutiny unlike contracts involving field training and combat exposure. The country has a complicated history with the use of foreign contractors to build the capacity of the military, particularly as the government rolls out efforts to reverse counter-terrorism setbacks in the Northeast. In early April, Nasir El-Rufai, governor of Nigeria's northwestern Kaduna State, threatened to bring in foreign mercenaries to fight the terrorists located in forest areas, if the federal government failed to tackle the problem. A month earlier, in February, Babagana Zulu, the governor of Borno, reiterated his call for hiring mercenaries. However, contracts with PMSCs, such as the Deep Blue Project which was managed by an Israeli firm, HLSI Security Systems and Technologies Limited, have more limited aims, such as strengthening the security of the country's territorial waters and the Gulf of Guinea.

The Rise of Mercenary Armies in Africa

April 15, 2022  |  Deutsche Welle

Foreign private military companies (PMCs) are being deployed in more and more crisis-ridden countries in Africa, but many mercenaries do not shy away from crimes and human rights violations. PMCs active in Africa include the Wagner Group, the Dyck Advisory Group (DAG), French company Secopex, U.K. companies Aegis Defence Services and G4S, Ukrainian company Omega Consulting Group, and Germany companies Xeless and Asgaard. Criticism of using mercenaries in Africa is growing. At the African Union summit in early February, the AU commissioner for poitical affairs, peace, and security Bankole Adeoye of Nigeria called for the "complete exclusion of mercenaries from the African continent."

Mali Massacre Survivors Say White Mercenaries Involved in Killings

April 14, 2022  |  Reuters

Survivors of a massacre in Moura, Mali, recall seeing Malian troops backed by white mercenaries executing residents of the town. Over four days, over 200 Malians were shot and thrown into a mass grave. Survivors of the massacre stated that white men in army fatigues who spoke what they believed was Russian were actively involved in the massacre. On April 5, the Malian army denied the allegations of a massacre and said it had conducted a professional operation to target Islamist militants in the town.

Foreign Mercenaries Is a Call to Anarchy

April 10, 2022  |  The Guardian Nigeria

The article, published in a Nigerian newspaper, argues that the use of mercenaries and private military companies is a call for anarchy as it undermines the "principles and concept of sovereignty" in Nigeria. The call against the use of mercenaries and PMCs comes after an attack on a train in Abuja-Kaduna which led to the Governor of Kaduna State, Nasir El-Rufai, to threaten to bring in foreign mercenaries to combat the insurgencies in Kaduna. The author also notes that the use of PMCs and mercenaries often leads to instability and government overthrows in the countries in which they are used.

Mali: Massacre by Army, Foreign Soldiers

April 05, 2022  |  Human Rights Watch

Malian armed forces and associated foreign fighters, thought to be from Russia, allegedly summarily executed an estimated 300 civilian men, some of them suspected Islamist fighters, in the central Malian town of Moura in late March 2022, Human Rights Watch said today. The incident is the worst single atrocity reported in Mali's decade-long armed conflict. Residents of Moura said they believed these solders were Russians, in part because Mali's transitional government said in December 2021, that "Russian trainers" were in Mali as part of a bilateral agreement with Russia.

Europe and Eurasia

The Mercenaries Behind the Bucha Massacre

April 12, 2022  |  The Wall Street Journal

Germany's foreign-intelligence service recently intercepted secret messages confirming Russian mercenaries known as the Wagner Group played a leading role in the massacre in Bucha, Ukraine. The Wagner Group has also faced accusations of human rights abuses in Syria, Libya, the Central African Repubic, Mali, and Ukraine.

What Is the Wagner Group, the Russian Mercenary Entity in Ukraine?

April 09, 2022  |  The Washington Post

Mercenaries working for a Kremlin-linked network of private military contractors have taken up arms in Ukraine on Russia's behalf, U.S. and British officials say. The network, known as the Wagner Group, first worked in Ukraine in 2014 during Russia's annexation of the Crimean Peninsula. In Russia's ongoing invasion of Ukraine, about 1,000 Wagner mercenaries are concentrated in the country's east, where Pentagon officials say Russia has refocused its war effort after failing to capture the capital, Kyiv. Germany's foreign intelligence service claimed to have intercepted communications that could link the Wagner Group to indiscriminate killings of Ukrainian civilians.

Foreign Fighters, Volunteers, and Mercenaries: Non-State Actors and Narratives in Ukraine

April 04, 2022  |  The Soufan Center

Russian mercenary and PMC groups have joined Russia's war on Ukraine. These include the Wagner Group, which played a central role in the illegal annexation of Crimea in 2014 and supported pro-Russia separatists waging war in eastern Ukraine. By some estimates, nearly 90% of the Wagner Group's manpower and resources have been moved from other theaters into Ukraine as of mid-March, highlighting the important role they are expected to play in the conflict. As these forces are moved out of active conflict zones abroad, or removed from contexts in which they are bolstering governments, it could lead to new power vacuums and opportunities for exploitation by terrorist groups or militias.

Near East (North Africa and the Middle East)

Libya: Landmines, Other War Hazards, Killing Civilians

April 27, 2022  |  Human Rights Watch

At least 130 people, mostly civilians, have been killed by landmines and abandoned or unexploded ordnance in Libya since the armed group called the Libyan Arab Armed Forces (LAAF) withdrew from Tripoli's southern suburbs in June 2020, Human Rights Watch reports. Fighters affiliated with the group, commanded by Khalifa Hiftar, and foreign fighters from Russia emplaced banned antipersonnel mines, including victim-activated improvised explosive devices and booby traps in Tripoli's southern suburbs, as they withdrew.

Contacts

John V. Parachini

johnvp@rand.org

Senior International and Defense Researcher

Melissa Shostak

mshostak@rand.org

Research Assistant

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis.

Privacy statement | Manage your subscription

Unsubscribe

RAND Corporation

RAND Corporation. 1776 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401-3208.
RAND® is a registered trademark.