In Focus: Private Military and Security Companies

Prepared by the RAND Corporation | July 2022

Members of the Wagner Group pose for a photo circa 2018 in Syria.  Photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine.

Members of the Wagner Group in Syria circa 2018
(photo courtesy of the Security Service of Ukraine)

This newsletter captures a selection of open-source material on Private Military and Security Companies (PMSCs) during June 2022. The United Nations defines PMSC as a corporate entity which provides on a compensatory basis military and/or security services by physical persons and/or legal entities. Military services include specialized services related to military actions, including strategic planning, intelligence, investigation, land, sea or air reconnaissance, flight operations of any type, manned or unmanned, satellite surveillance, any kind of knowledge transfer with military applications, material and technical support to armed forces and other related activities. Security services include armed guarding or protection of buildings, installations, property and people, any kind of knowledge transfer with security and policing applications, development and implementation of informational security measures and other related activities. In the context of this newsletter, malign activities are those activities undertaken by a PMSC which are illegal, destabilizing, or escalatory. The RAND Corporation seeks credible open-source material and curates but does not verify the content of the open-source material in this monthly summary with the support of U.S. government foreign assistance funding to raise awareness of the activities of PMSCs.

Africa (sub-Sahara)  |  Europe and Eurasia  |  Near East (North Africa and the Middle East)  |  Western Hemisphere

Africa (sub-Sahara)

The EU's New Plan to Counter Russian Mercenaries Is Dead on Arrival

June 29, 2022  |  Real Clear Defense

The EU intends to launch three security force assistance missions to Niger, Burkina Faso, and an unspecified nation in the Gulf of Guinea. The proposed EU missions in West Africa and the Sahel are explicitly designed to keep Wagner out of the region. The EU's report blames the arrival of "Russia-affiliated forces" in Mali for destabilizing the country. Wagner, in Brussels' opinion, is "gradually more present and influent at the strategic level" in Africa as Wagner's success has been convincing African leaders that France and the EU are unreliable security partners. However, these missions will not prevent Wagner's expansion in Africa as the countries chosen are not very susceptible to a Wagner deployment, and deployments to these regions may overstep what was requested of them, leading to degradation of EU relations in these countries without guaranteeing security.

Russia's Wagner Group in Mali Spurs Refugee Spike in Mauritania

June 28, 2022  |  Al Jazeera

Refugees from northern Mali have flooded into refugee camps in Mauritania following the start of operations by Wagner Group mercenaries in Mali. When asked by Al Jazeera about their reasons for fleeing Mali, some refugees either cited the Russians specifically as a threat or said that the security situation in Mali's decade-long war has gotten worse since Wagner mercenaries arrived at the beginning of 2022. Ousmane Diallo, a Dakar-based researcher for Amnesty International noted that "the abuses and the violations by the Malian army" have increased in "the scale and brutality" since the arrival of the Wagner Group.

Russian Mercenaries Accused of Deadly Attacks on Mines Sudan-CAR Border

June 21, 2022  |  The Guardian

Russian mercenaries have mounted a series of attacks on artisanal mines in the border zones between Sudan and Central African Republic (CAR) in an effort to plunder the region's valuable gold trade, witnesses and experts have said. Dozens of miners are thought to have died in at least three major attacks this year allegedly involving mercenaries working for the Wagner Group. There are also reports of further attacks on mines in at least six other places across CAR.

China Using Private Military Companies to Expand Its Footprint in Africa

June 13, 2022  |  The Economic Times of India

The presence of Chinese private security companies (PSCs) in Africa is expected to increase Beijing's interference in the country, human rights violations, and illegal activities. China has been using PSCs as a plot to maintain a discreet military presence in Africa and avoid being seen as another colonial power. Despite Chinese claims that PSCs are involved in providing passive security services, such as access control and protection of citizens and property, covert activities, such as spying, gathering of intelligence, and advising local forces, have also been observed.

Addressing the Increase in Human Rights Violations Committed by the Malian Defence and Security Forces and the Wagner Group

June 13, 2022  |  GOV.UK

James Kariuki, the UK ambassador to the UN Security Council, denounced human rights violations committed by the Russian Wagner Group in Mali. The Wagner Group has been tied to the massacre in Moura that killed hundreds of Malian civilians. MINUMSA has been denied access to this site to conduct an independent investigation.

How the West Can Win Back the Central African Republic

June 10, 2022  |  IPS

The Central African Republic (CAR) is now an arena of geopolitical conflict involving the new "player" Russia and the former colonial power France. CAR may serve as a blueprint for a reorientation of African states on the world stage, and Russian success is partially based off of frustrations by locals regarding UN and European responses to terrorism threats in the country. Europe can win back influence in CAR by launching a training mission in the country which places locals on equal footing with European partners. Furthermore, Europe needs to move away from prioritizing the military and putting emphasis on a broad-based civil partnership, building up civil society in the country, containing violence, and fostering peaceful coexistence.

Wagner Tactics Push Civilians toward Extremists

June 07, 2022  |  ADF

The human rights atrocities committed by the Wagner Group in Mali are indicative of a broader trend for Wagner Group activity within Africa. In exchange for security training and assistance in operations, Wagner sometimes receives mining contracts which allow the group to sell gold and other resources for payment. As a result of Wagner's violence, civilians in Mali are turning to protection from the same extremist groups that the Malian military is targeting, leading to destabilization of the country and the continent.

Europe and Eurasia

Russian Air Force Struggling in Ukraine Because of Combat Losses: UK

June 24, 2022  |  Newsweek

An intelligence update provided by the Ministry of Defence noted that Russia has moved to using retired personnel who are now working as contractors for the Wagner Group to conduct close air support missions. The ministry said that the use of retired personnel, now working as Wagner contractors, indicates that the Russian Aerospace Forces are likely struggling to support the invasion of Ukraine with sufficient aircrew, and that this is likely due to a combination of Russia's insufficient numbers of suitably trained personnel and its combat losses.

Meet the Irregular Troops Backing up Russia's Army in the Kharkiv Region

June 17, 2022  |  Bellingcat

Fighters from several private military companies (PMCs) and irregular groups, including the Wagner Group, the Borey Group, and the Cossack Don group, are involved in the fighting in eastern Ukraine near Kharkiv. The use of contractors and irregular forces has allowed Russia to address manpower issues as the war in Ukraine continues on. Pavel Luzin, a Russian political analyst, notes that the Russian authorities do not only mercenaries as "gun fodder" but also as a tool for preventing political threats within Russia by limiting the losses in the regular forces and eliminating mercenaries who could potentially become domestic threats if allowed to return to Russia.

Near East (North Africa and the Middle East)

Africa Loses Gold Deposit Sovereignty and Turns into Russian Colony

June 29, 2022  |  Robert Lansing Institute for Global Threats and Democratic Studies

Sudan has lost effective control over its gold deposits. Moscow is expanding its presence in the country and is getting more involved in mining by using corrupt ties with the military junta in Khartoum. Such relations establish colonial relations between Russia and the region. Russia ensures protection of the regime and its worldwide recognition in exchange for getting an access to African resources, undermining the local population.

Spain Warns NATO of Russian Threat in Africa

June 26, 2022  |  PBS News Hour

Spain and other NATO member states are pushing the Western alliance to consider how mercenaries aligned with Russian President Vladimir Putin are spreading Moscow's influence to Africa. The Russian Wagner Group, which has links to the Kremlin, has developed footholds in Libya, Mali, Sudan, and Central African Republic (CAR). Spain emphasized that this Russian expansion into Africa, including the use of Wagner Group mercenaries, put Spain and NATO's southern flank at risk. Additionally, former NATO Secretary-General Javier Solana noted that instability in other countries in the Sahel, particularly Morocco and Algeria, present a risk of Wagner expansion in the region, which, in turn, threatens NATO.

Lavrov: Wagner in Libya for Commercial Reasons upon Tobruk Authorities' Request

June 19, 2022  |  The Libya Observer

The Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov stated that the presence of Wagner Group mercenaries in Libya is "on a commercial basis," saying that the private security company was invited by the authorities in Tobruk, referring to the House of Representatives. Lavrov added that Wagner mercenaries are also in Mali on a commercial basis and then reiterated Russia's official position that Wagner is unaffiliated with the Russian state.

"From Russia with Love": A Putin Ally Mines Gold and Plays Favorites in Sudan

June 05, 2022  |  The New York Times

The Russian Wagner Group has obtained lucrative Sudanese mining concessions that produce gold, a potential boost to the Kremlin's $130 billion in gold reserves that American officials worry is being used to blunt the effect of economic sanctions over the Ukraine war by propping up the ruble. In eastern Sudan, Wagner is supporting the Kremlin's push to build a naval base on the Red Sea to host its nuclear-powered warships. In western Sudan, it has found a launchpad for its mercenary operations in neighboring countries, and a possible source of uranium. Since Sudan's military seized power in a coup in October, Wagner has intensified its partnership with Lt. Gen. Mohamed Hamdan and supported his efforts to suppress a pro-democracy movement.

EU Court Rejects Appeal by Alleged Financier of Wagner Group in Libya

June 02, 2022  |  Asharq Al-Awsat

A top EU court rejected a bid by Kremlin-linked oligarch Yevgeny Prigozhin, the alleged financier of the Wagner Group, to overturn sanctions imposed over the conflict in Libya. Prigozhin claimed that he had "no knowledge of an entity known as the Wagner Group" and said the EU had failed to justify the move to apply sanctions. The EU's General Court rejected his case and confirmed the sanctions against him, stating that the bloc had provided "specific, precise and consistent evidence demonstrating the numerous close links between Prigozhin and Wagner Group."

Western Hemisphere

It's Time to Designate Wagner Group as a Foreign Terrorist Organization

June 30, 2022  |  Lawfare

International sanctions to punish Russia for its invasion of Ukraine have overlooked a key component in the Kremlin's toolbox for international terror and coercion: the private military company (PMC) Wagner Group, which is owned by Vladimir Putin confidant Yevgeny Prigozhin. To effectively end the Kremlin's use of Wagner Group as a covert tool of terror, the U.S. should designate Wagner Group as a foreign terrorist organization (FTO). This would allow the Treasury Department to freeze the Wagner Group's assets, bar members of Wagner Group from entering the United States, subject those who knowingly provide "material support or resources" to U.S. criminal prosecution, and provide civil remedies to U.S. persons who are victims of a terrorist act committed by the Wagner Group. If the U.S. recognizes the Wagner Group as an FTO would likely lead to other countries and international organizations applying similar sanctions.

Contacts

John V. Parachini

johnvp@rand.org

Senior International and Defense Researcher

Melissa Shostak

mshostak@rand.org

Research Assistant

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis.

Privacy statement | Manage your subscription

Unsubscribe

RAND Corporation

RAND Corporation. 1776 Main Street, Santa Monica, CA 90401-3208.
RAND® is a registered trademark.