Characteristics of high-performing research units in UK higher education institutions (HEIs)
Research for the Higher Education Funding Council of England shows that five key themes are associated with high performance in UK higher education institutions: people; culture, values and leadership; strategy and funding; collaboration and networks; and institutional and departmental practice.
Recruiting and the retaining the best staff is considered a key pre-requisite characteristic of success and central to high performance.
The Higher Education Funding Council for England (HEFCE) commissioned the Policy Institute at King’s and RAND Europe to conduct a preliminary analysis of the characteristics of high performing research units within UK Higher Education Institutions (HEIs).
The resulting report looks at characteristics shared between research units whose submissions in the Research Excellence Framework 2014 (REF) scored highly in the areas of research and impact, to identify aspects of characterisation that merit further investigation.
The report focuses on the broad characteristics of research units or departments and therefore has a wider remit than performance in the REF per se. The report is not a guide to tactical approaches for performing well in the REF; rather it focuses on strategic approaches to delivering excellent research.
To identify key characteristics of high-performing research units the project team sourced and triangulated evidence through interviews and a workshop with academics from high-performing research units, from quantitative data from HESA and REF 2014 submissions, and from existing literature.
From the analysis the project team identified eight observations that are associated with high research performance and warrant further investigation. They are:
- In high-performing research units more of the staff have PhDs, professorial positions, international experience and externally funded salaries.
- High-performing research units prioritise recruiting the best and retaining them.
- High-performing research units provide training and mentorship programmes to develop staff, while offering rewards for strong performance.
- The leaders of high-performing research units have earned ‘accountable autonomy’ within their higher education institution.
- Staff within high-performing research units display a distinct ethos of social and ethical values.
- High-performing research units have strategies that are real, living and owned, and more than merely a written document.
- High-performing research units receive more income per researcher than the average research unit.
- High-performing research units enable and encourage researchers to initiate collaborations organically as opposed to using a top down approach.
Following RAND Europe's evaluation of the Research Excellence Framework submission process, the four UK higher education funding bodies commissioned an evaluation of the assessment process for the impact element of the REF 2014.
To contribute to the Medical Research Council's objective of funding studies that "deliver user/beneficiary views on the contribution of academic research and MRC input," researchers are refining and adapting a survey-based approach known as Best-Worst Scaling (BWS) to analyse the relative valuations of research impact as perceived by the general population and researchers.
For the first time anywhere, the UK has allocated funding to universities according to an assessment of research impact. An evaluation of the Research Excellence Framework 2014 process reveals that it worked, allowing different types of impacts drawn from a wide range of disciplines to be compared and scored.