What Is in This Module?

This module focuses on health and well-being narratives in your community and the underlying frames (values or beliefs) guiding those narratives. Narratives include these frames and the resulting stories and messaging that influence and inform the way people and communities see the world.

In this module, you will work to guide your community to build a narrative with a strong focus on health equity and well-being and a particular emphasis on collective well-being. As described later in this module, narratives are key to motivating a community to consistently act on behalf of health and well-being.

We recommend that you complete this module before working on other modules (particularly Module 3, Measuring for Action, and Module 4, Connecting Intention to Action).

As a reminder, the definitions of terms such as health equity and collective well-being are in the glossary. These two terms serve as the pillars of each toolkit module.

Use this module to invite leaders in your community into conversations about health and well-being narratives. See the introduction if you are unsure about which leaders to include. As with other modules in this toolkit, this module includes new concepts, discussion prompts, and group exercises. It can be facilitated by a group leader or worked on collaboratively in a group setting.

Facilitator Instructions Materials Needed for In-Person Sessions

  • A computer or mobile device (if using the digital toolkit)
  • A whiteboard or large easel pad in a central location for group exercises
  • Easel pads for each small group
  • Markers (enough for each small group)
  • Printouts of the resources provided at the end of the toolkit (e.g., Participant Workbook, glossary) to provide as handouts; printouts of module pages for those who do not have a computer or mobile device
  • Optional sticky notes or notepads for individual brainstorming
  • Pens, markers, and paper for notetaking, if preferred

Skills Acquired to Walk the Talk

By the end of this module, Walking the Talk, your community will be able to

  • explain what narrative is and why it matters for advancing health and well-being in your community
  • describe some of the values and beliefs that underlie your community’s views and actions related to health and well-being
  • identify ways that your community’s health narrative can sharpen a focus on health equity and collective well-being specifically.
Discussion

Introductory Discussion Prompt

Here are some ideas for icebreakers that you can use before starting this module with your community group. Ask each participant to share the following:

  • What is your name?
  • What organization do you represent?
  • When our community is healthy, it feels like ____.
  • When our community is healthy, it looks like ____.

Section A Explaining Narrative

Key Terms What is narrative?

  • A narrative includes the critical frames and resulting stories and messages that influence and inform the way people and communities see the world. A narrative helps to articulate a way of understanding the world and informs how people then act.

  • Narrative is not a branding or messaging campaign. It is also not a set of talking points.

  • Narrative goes deeper. It focuses on culture, history, and values (frames) at the root of a community, which drive how community members act, what they choose to prioritize, and what messages and stories they share.

  • The frames of a narrative (sometimes the root values and beliefs) are taken forward by influencers in a community and affect actions in that community.

Visual

Visuals to Share

Figures 2.1 and 2.2 can be shared in a group meeting to explain these concepts further. Figure 2.1 is meant to help participants visualize the components of narrative.

Figure 2.1 The Components of Narrative
Graphic describing the impact of a narrative using a tree as a metaphor
Source: This figure is reproduced with permission from the MetropolitanGroup.

Figure Details

An infographic titled "Narratives and the Power They Hold to Change the World" explains the concept and impact of narratives. Text at the top reads "For those seeking to advance a more just, healthy, and sustainable world, narrative can be one of the most powerful tools. The narratives we accept—and the narratives we reject—reveal something about ourselves, the world we see, and the change we seek to create or the status quo we strive to protect. No narrative exists in a vacuum. It is deeply influenced by—and in turn can influence changes in—the social, cultural, environmental, and political ecosystems all around us. Similarly, while the mindsets people hold shape their receptivity or resistance to narratives, narratives can also influence changes in people’s mindsets.

  • At the center is a tree representing a narrative, which is defined as "The articulation of a particular way of understanding the world and how it works that shapes what people think, believe, and do."
  • The tree has three key components:
  • Stories (leaves): Located at the top of the tree, stories are explained as "What people experience over time both literally (e.g., through social media, oral tradition, etc.) and figuratively (e.g., through policy, the built environment, etc.) that aggregates to create or reinforce a particular narrative."
  • Messaging (the trunk): Defined as "The core ideas that provide the foundational structure for the narrative."
  • Values (the roots): Explained as "The deeply held beliefs that ground the narrative; connect it to what people care about; and increase their likelihood of attention, adoption, and action."
  • Supporting elements include:
  • Ecosystem (globe icon, middle-left): Described as "The contexts in which people are exposed to narrative, including their environment, lived experience, and the echo chambers through which they receive information."
  • Mindsets (red silhouette of a human head, middle-right): Defined as "The collection of perspectives and attitudes that shapes people’s receptivity or resistance to narratives and to changes in behavior, social norms, or policies/systems."

The diagram visually connects the narrative tree to ecosystem and mindsets, emphasizing the interdependence of these factors in shaping perceptions and driving change.

Going deeper, frames (or the roots of a narrative) are used by a variety of influential people (individuals, organizations) and can result in actions in a community, such as shifting the culture around an issue, a programmatic change, or a policy change (Figure 2.2).

Figure 2.2 The Elements of Narrative
A diagram illustrating the interconnection between three elements: Frames, Influencers, and Actions, under the overarching concept of Elements of Narrative
Source: Adapted from Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, 2022.

Figure Details

A diagram illustrating the interconnection between three elements: Frames, Influencers, and Actions, under the overarching concept of "Elements of Narrative."

  • At the top, a box labeled "Elements of Narrative" leads to a box labeled "Frames." Two arrows descend from "Frames," connecting to two boxes below.
  • On the left, a box labeled "Influencers" lists examples: Individuals, Organizations, and Collective Leadership.
  • On the right, a box labeled "Actions" lists examples: Cultural Shifts, Programmatic Change, and Policy Change. The boxes are all connected by horizontal double-sided arrows, indicating bidirectional interactions between Frames, Influencers, and Actions.

Key Terms Why are narratives important?

Narratives can be very influential, and they are important to both analyze and develop for the following reasons:

  • Narratives provide a “North Star” (i.e., a source of direction) to guide action.

  • Narratives offer the ability to

    • mobilize a community toward a common aspiration or goal
    • connect disparate efforts to align on overarching messages and stories
    • emotionally and practically anchor a vision of health progress.
  • Currently, there is no cohesive health narrative in the United States. As noted in the Sentinel Communities project, communities are unclear about what the overarching U.S. health narrative is. Is it about containing health care costs? Is it about mitigating disease? Is it about promoting health? Or something else? For information about what we learned in Sentinel Communities, read more in Appendix B and C in the annex to this toolkit.

  • The absence of a cohesive health narrative leaves communities without a clear North Star to guide their actions, which diminishes their ability to mobilize toward common aspirations, connect disparate efforts, and anchor a vision of health progress, resulting in fragmented and less effective health initiatives.

Using the discussion prompts for this section, you will work through some exercises to try to get a feel for the narratives that exist in your community. In later exercises, you will explore elements of narrative frames that could help you generate a more productive health narrative to guide your efforts.

Discussion

Discussion Prompt 2A.1: Exploring Existing Community Narratives

Consider the following questions individually and then share your responses in a group discussion. In the next discussion, you will reconsider the same questions but with a focus on health.

  1. What are some ways that people in this community would describe life here?
  2. In what ways does this view or vision shape or inform community efforts?

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

Spend two to three minutes answering the questions individually using notepads, sticky notes, or the provided Participant Workbook. Have participants post their answers on a large poster board or in a central location.

Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.

Discussion

Discussion Prompt 2A.2: Exploring Community Health Narratives

Consider the following questions individually and then share your responses in a group discussion.

  1. What are some ways that people in this community would describe health here?
  2. In what ways does this view or vision shape or inform community efforts around health?

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

Spend two to three minutes answering the questions individually using notepads, sticky notes, or the provided Participant Workbook. Have participants post their answers on a large poster board or in a central location.

Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.

Here are some additional questions you can pose to the group during discussion:

  • In what ways are these existing narratives supportive of our efforts to improve health and well-being? What about health equity?
  • In what ways might they be holding us back? (Think about how narratives affect our ability to connect different sectors to the task of improving health or connect efforts that are specific to different topics or health issues.)

Talking Points The concept of narrative might feel too complex or disconnected from the daily experiences of the community

During discussions about health, community members might struggle with the toolkit’s significant focus on narrative. If this concern arises in your group discussions, here is one way to make the case for the importance of narrative:

Studies have shown that American mindsets and expectations about health really matter.

Studies by RAND, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, and other organizations indicate that the American public’s views on health can affect their communities’ ability to achieve their health goals (Chandra et al., 2024). For instance, many Americans equate health with health care and fail to recognize the influence of social and environmental factors on health outcomes. Additionally, many Americans remain dissatisfied with health outcomes and doubt their community’s ability to work together to improve health. These points are just a sampling that highlight the importance of starting community health efforts with an understanding of health values, beliefs, and experiences.

Section B Unpacking Frames

In this section, we will dive deeper into the concept of frames—the root values and beliefs in a community.

Key Terms What is a frame or community belief or value?

Frames are the underlying values and beliefs that influence something, such as a health outcome.

Many factors can influence frames, such as the

  • history of a community
  • experiences in a community
  • community’s culture
  • mindsets
    (i.e., the beliefs, attitudes, and assumptions of a person or group) of community members or the community overall.
Visual

Visual to Share, with an Opportunity for Discussion

Figure 2.3 breaks down frames as an element of narrative. It can be shared as a handout or projected in your meeting. Refer to the instructions for ways to discuss community values when using this visual.

Figure 2.3 The Elements of Narrative (Frames)
Graphic depicting factors that influence frames which are the roots in the tree metaphor

Figure Details

  • A diagram titled "Elements of Narrative" is divided into two sections.
  • On the left side, a list labeled "Some factors that influence frames" includes: mindsets, values, experiences, culture, and history. These factors point to a horizontal box labeled "Frames."
  • On the right side, a tree illustration visualizes the narrative structure. The tree's leaves are labeled "Stories," the trunk is labeled "Messaging," and the roots are labeled "Frame," signifying that frames form the foundation of narratives. There is a circle around “Frame” to indicate that this graphic is focused on the Frames element of narrative.

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

As a group, consider the question:

  • What are our community’s values?

Some examples could include “justice for all” or “neighbors helping neighbors.” Write down the community values that your group comes up with on a large easel pad or in another central location. These values should not necessarily be related to health and well-being but should reflect the broader culture and ethos of your community. Continue the exercise for ten minutes, depending on group size.

Key Terms What frames about health and well-being showed up in Sentinel Communities

Now you will dive specifically into frames that relate to health and well-being. The following frames were identified in Sentinel Communities:

  • Health is an individual’s responsibility.

  • We (meaning this community) should reverse alarming health trends, with intensive, focused action on a specific health issue that has emerged.

  • Strengthening the economy is a priority, and health benefits are a bonus.

  • Healthy people need healthy environments.

  • It is time to address health equity and systemic racism.

Not all frames were present in all communities, and not all communities had only one frame. But communities often had a dominant frame that informed their health actions.

To advance health equity and collective well-being—the two pillars of this toolkit—we highlight frames that focus on social and environmental drivers of health (e.g., healthy people need healthy environments) as important and helpful.

Group

Group Exercise 2B.3: Community Health Frames—What Factors Are Influencing Health Frames?

Here is a group exercise to try out what you have learned so far in this module. Discuss these questions in small groups and then share your responses in a larger group discussion:

  • Values: What are some of the values in our community? By values we mean principles or standards of behavior (e.g., the value of teamwork, self-reliance). How do the values that were raised in the previous discussion relate to health?
  • Experiences and history: What do you think are some factors from our community’s history that influence how it addresses health issues? Has our community had recent experiences related to health that might shape our beliefs—for example, a health initiative that worked or did not, community economic choices, or political changes in the community?
  • Culture: What are some of the cultures that our community builds from (e.g., ancestries, traditions, nationalities), and how do these cultures show up in how people view health or approach health actions?

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

We advise forming small groups of no more than six people. To ensure robust discussion, groups should reflect different perspectives and community sectors. Ask groups to discuss these questions for ten to fifteen minutes. Then, reconvene to have them share their answers.

Here are some additional questions you can pose to the group during discussion:

  • In this discussion, what stuck out for you in the points raised by your peers?
  • Are there common themes or connections among these ideas?

The information discussed during this exercise can be documented in the Participant Workbook.

Section C Shaping Stories About Health Equity

In this section, you will apply the community frames that you identified in the prior sections to the stories about health equity and collective well-being that circulate in your community. The objective of this section is to consider how the current frames in your community (informed by values, history, and so forth) can be used to advance dialogue and action on health equity and collective well-being.

Key Terms For this section, it might help to recall this toolkit’s definition of health equity (see Module 1 and the glossary): the fair and just access to the opportunity to be healthy for all.

Talking Points Health equity is not a term we can use in our community.

As also noted in Module 1, different communities approach the issue of health equity in different ways. Sometimes the word equity might not be useful or desirable. Fortunately, there are other ways to approach this concept. What is important is not the specific term but finding ways to help different people, groups, and neighborhoods lead healthier lives.

Here are some options for terms that could help keep the conversation going. Think about which term or terms might work best for your community:

  • health opportunities
  • social contexts around health
  • fairness in health
  • health for all
  • health choices
Discussion

Discussion Prompt 2C.4: Why Are Some People Unhealthy?

Consider the following question individually and then share your responses in a group discussion:

  • What do people in our community say are the reasons for why some people are unhealthy?

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

Spend two to three minutes answering the questions individually using notepads, sticky notes, or the Participant Workbook. Have participants post their answers on a large poster board or in a central location.

Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.

Here are some additional questions you can pose to the group during discussion:

  • Looking at the reasons that people gave for why some people are unhealthy in this community, what feels most relevant?
  • What were the frames guiding those ideas? How do those ideas relate to our community’s values, experience and history, and culture?

Talking Points What do the American people think about the topic of health equity?

It is important to recognize what people generally understand or feel about health equity, as this information can affect how you might view your own community’s attitudes. Read on for more information about national perspectives on health equity and how communities are approaching this issue. Familiarizing yourself and your community with such data can inform whether your community prioritizes a health equity issue and the narrative the community might advance for health and well-being.

  • Many communities have health plans that include a focus on health equity. Sometimes these plans are part of community health needs assessments; sometimes, they are part of broader community strategies or development plans.

  • Researchers at RAND and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation have studied where the U.S. public is on this topic, with the recognition that other research has already demonstrated that some groups (e.g., low-income groups, racial minority and ethnic minority groups) are confronted with more barriers when attempting to gain access to health care. In the National Survey of Health Attitudes, which RAND and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation fielded periodically between 2015 and 2023 (Chandra et al., 2024), the researchers posed the following question: How much harder or easier is it for different groups to get health care?

  • 69 percent of respondents thought it was more difficult for low-income Americans to get health care than those with higher incomes. 31 percent of respondents said it was easier for low-income Americans to get health care or there was no difference in health care access based on income.

  • 43 percent of respondents thought it was more difficult for Black Americans to get health care compared with White Americans. 57 percent of respondents said it was easier for Black Americans to get health care or there was no difference in access to health care between Black and White Americans.

Talking Points What do U.S. communities think about this topic?

The Sentinel Communities project shows that communities are approaching health equity and related topics differently. Some focus on closing gaps between groups (e.g., thinking about how to resolve disparities in health outcomes between groups). Others focus on creating positive ripple effects (i.e., “lifting all boats”) through initiatives that are geared toward economic or educational opportunity and that have the goal of positively influencing health. Other communities are focused on the structures and systems that might have created the conditions for existing health inequities. Understanding where your community stands in relation to these three categories will help you determine the dominant health narratives in your community and how you might address the underlying frames of those narratives.

Visual

Visuals to Share

Figure 2.4 can be shared in a group meeting to depict the three approaches to health equity.

Figure 2.4 Three Approaches to Health Equity
Graphic of a table to spark discussion about local communities and their focuses
Source: Adapted from Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, 2019.

Figure Details

A figure that consists of three overlapping horizontal arrows transitioning from left to right. The arrows illustrate a progression of community focus on health equity and text describes areas of community change, approach, and perspective that relate to each approach to equity.

Approach to Equity Focused on disparities Focused on economics and education Focused on structures and systems
Community change Screening for cancer among at-risk populations Job-skill matching for improved employment Instituting an Office of Equity to affect local decisionmaking
Approach Targeting high-need populations for intervention Broad-based changes with nonspecific equity goals Creating new government structures
Perspective Reducing health disparities Increasing economic and/or educational opportunities Addressing historical and systems-level barriers

A box includes the text: “Discussion: Where do you see your community in this figure?”

As you look at the figure, consider the following question as a group:

  • Where does your community fit in the three categories in this figure?
  • Are you a community that is focused on disparities, a community that is taking a broad approach to economic and/or educational opportunity with the aim of influencing health, or a community that is focused on making systemic changes to address health inequities?
Group

Group Exercise 2C.5: Shifting the Frame on Health Equity and Seeding New Stories

The following is a group exercise in which you will try to help make the case for why health equity matters. In the context of Figure 2.1, you are now moving from the frames of narrative (i.e., the roots, which symbolize values and beliefs) up into the branches and leaves of narrative (which symbolize stories).

You will be assigned to represent one of three community sectors. If you have a large group, you can identify another sector to represent (e.g., another government department, another community-based organization focused on a different topic area). The three community sectors are a

  1. government agency focused on community needs other than health (e.g., public works, public safety)
  2. for-profit business
  3. community-based organization focused on economic opportunity and families.

In your small groups, develop a set of messages and one compelling short story (no more than one page) about why improving health equity matters in your community for that sector. You can also act out the story or use a whiteboard or easel pad to illustrate the story. The goal here is to shift the frame so that you are convincing a sector (e.g., business, media) to better understand why health equity is part of the sector’s responsibility. You will use a story format to try to achieve that shift in the sector’s understanding of its role.

Consider the following points made in prior exercises in this module:

  • Why are some people unhealthy in this community, and what are frames guiding health narratives in our community?
  • What are the dominant health narratives, and how do they account for health equity, if at all?

If you would like an example or prompt, feel free to use the scenario below.

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

Create groups of no more than six people. Take 20 minutes for groups to develop a story and a set of messages to deliver to the sector with which they are communicating (or convincing). The goal here is to shift a frame on why health equity matters for that sector. There are fields in the Participant Workbook to write these stories and messages down, but each group should also use easel pads and markers to document their work.

When the groups come back together, the group leader or facilitator can prompt questions, such as the following:

  • Why did you choose those messages? What were you trying to appeal to in your specific sector’s health frames?
  • Do you think the set of messages and the story that your group created will compel that sector to engage in the community actions for health equity? Why or why not?

An Example Start to Changing the Frame on Health Equity

An employer is trying to figure out why issues of health equity might matter to the Company’s board and why the Company should consider investing in community health as part of its corporate social responsibility. The leadership in the city where the Company is based is trying to get all organizations to help advance the city’s health equity strategy. In a conversation between the chief executive officer (CEO) of the Company and the mayor, the following points are made:

  • The CEO says, “We already fund health insurance and the employee wellness program. Isn’t that enough? We don’t have a broader role in health equity because that issue doesn’t affect our bottom line.”
  • The mayor responds, “That isn’t quite true, Ms. CEO. A lack of health equity has ripple effects across the economy. Some estimates indicate that health inequities cost the U.S. economy $450 billion a year. When an issue has that type of effect on the economy, all sectors, including the business sector, have a role to play in addressing it. Plus, communities are filled with consumers, and healthy community members make active consumers.”

Section D Shaping Stories About Collective Well-Being

In this section, you will try to apply the community frames that you identified in the prior sections to stories about shaping collective well-being for your community. The objective of this section is to consider how the current frames in the community (informed by values, history, and so forth) can be used to advance dialogue and action on collective well-being.

Table 2.1. Definitions of Well-Being
Well-being
The full range of assets and capabilities that people need to thrive and create meaningful futures
Individual well-being
The state in which people experience happiness and satisfaction and can realize their full potential
Community well-being
The combination of social, economic, environmental, cultural, and political conditions identified by individuals, families, and their communities as essential for them to flourish and fulfill their potential
Collective well-being

The expression of the connections between individual and community well-being

When communities (e.g., places or cultures) are characterized by a strong collective well-being, they have the collective will and connected experiences that will allow community members to work together to address systemic harms and build a future together. For instance, collective well-being can refer to the strength and quality of connections among people, between people and institutions in the community, and between people and nature.

Key Terms

Recall the definition of well-being for this toolkit (see Module 1 and glossary).

Talking Points "Well-being is a difficult term for people to understand in my community"

Sometimes, a term such as well-being can be challenging. For some, it can incorrectly mean wellness and is linked with mindfulness or exercise programs (e.g., meditation, yoga). For others, it can seem like an out-of-reach, aspirational state. If your community does not respond to the term well-being, that is okay as long as you keep in mind the two most important aspects of well-being as a concept.

  • A comprehensive view of health: Ensure that health actions in your community consider the multiple and holistic dimensions of health (e.g., social, emotional, physical, cultural, spiritual).
  • A positive redefinition of health: Focus on health not just as the absence of disease but as actions and choices that build positive assets to reach individual and community potential (you can think about it as thriving and not just surviving).

Although they are not the same as well-being, here are some other terms that could be used:

  • positive health
  • hope
  • thriving and flourishing
  • quality of life

Given this toolkit’s focus on different types of well-being in general and its emphasis on collective well-being in particular, such phrases as improving connections could also work.

Key Terms Where are communities getting stuck when trying to advance well-being?

Check out Module 1 for more information about why well-being matters. What key points should communities address to advance action? Consider the following points:

  • emphasizing the importance of positive health (not just the absence of disease)
  • finding ways to discuss progress (e.g., including well-being indicators and not just economic ones)
  • avoiding a focus on one siloed health condition after another or the creation of short term fixes that fail to connect the dots—for example, the COVID-19 response failed to connect the dots between physical health and emotional well-being
  • promoting well-being by investing in its various dimensions (e.g., social, cultural, structural).

Here are some examples to illustrate what differentiates a community that centers well-being:

  • A community with an economy based on well-being would focus not just on providing jobs but also on meaningful work (Wellbeing Economy, undated).
  • A community focused on well-being would not just deliver individual mental health interventions but also work on the connections between people to support social connection.
Discussion

Discussion Prompt 2D.6: Messages About Well-Being

Consider the following questions to get your group talking about the messages about well-being that circulate in your community:

  • How do people in our community talk about well-being?
  • What have you heard people in our community say about what helps them feel hopeful for the future?

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

Spend two to three minutes answering the questions individually using notepads, sticky notes, or the Participant Workbook. Have participants post their answers on a large poster board or in a central location.

Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.

Here are some additional questions you can pose to the group during discussion:

  • Looking at the messages that people gave about how people in this community talk about well-being, what feels most resonant?
  • What were the frames guiding the ideas in those messages? How do those ideas relate to our community’s values, experiences and history, and culture?
Group

Group Exercise 2D.7: Shifting the Frame on Collective Well-Being and Seeding New Stories

The following is a group exercise in which you will try to help make the case for why collective well-being matters. Because you will focus on collective well-being, it is important to emphasize the role of connection noted in the definition of collective well-being in this module and the glossary.

For this group exercise, you will be assigned a health issue. If you have a large group, you can identify another health issue that has come up in your community if it is not already listed. The health issues are

  1. mental or behavioral health
  2. housing availability, stability, or homelessness
  3. healthy food access.

In your small groups, develop a set of messages and one compelling short story (no more than one page) that link your health issue to a broader focus on collective well-being in your community. As with the previous group exercise on health equity, you can act out the story or use a whiteboard or easel pad to illustrate the story. The goal here is to shift the frame so that a sector can better understand why a typical health issue can and should be framed in the context of improving collective well-being and to use a story format to try to achieve that shift.

Consider the points made in prior exercises in this module. What are people in your community saying about well-being and such related topics as hope and connection? What are some of the reasons for these views? If you would like an example or prompt, feel free to use the scenario below.

See Advancing a Well-Being Narrative (Messenger, Gunst, and Chandra, 2022) for examples of how different sectors may contribute to advancing well-being narratives.

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

We advise forming small groups of no more than six people. To ensure robust discussion, groups should reflect different perspectives and community sectors.

Groups should take 20 minutes to develop their story and set of messages for the health topic assigned. There are fields in the Participant Workbook to write these stories and messages down, but each group should also use an easel pad and markers to document their work.

Here are some additional questions you can pose to the group during discussion:

  • Why did you choose those messages? What were you trying to appeal to in your specific sector’s health frames?
  • Do you think you can tell a broader story of collective well-being as you work on health issues in your community? Why or why not?

An Example Story on Collective Well-Being

A spike in suicides among youth in Everytown has community leaders worried. Everyone is scrambling for the right solution to the issue. Does it involve providing more mental health services in schools or banning social media? Should the focus be on getting more young people into after-school programs?

A meeting of community leaders—both adults and youth—is convened to address the issue. Vocal advocates in the community argue for their version of the right solution.

Their arguments are as follows:

  • The youth say, “We have to step back here and look at what has been driving this issue. How are the concerns for youth in our community connected? If we focus on dealing only with suicides, then we are already too late. Youth are dealing with other issues such as anxiety and depression, loneliness, and a lack of hope for the future.”
  • The community leaders look to the recent past and question what has been happening in the community over the past few years. They ask the following questions:
    • Have neighborhoods become detached from each other?
    • Are groups connected?
    • Do we even know how youth are feeling about their lives? We have a lot of data on suicide now, but what about the factors that affect a child before they become suicidal, such as anxiety, depression, loneliness, and bullying?
    • What investments are being made to help youth socially, emotionally, spiritually, and otherwise?
    • In addition to each individual young person, does the community feel well?
  • The leaders realize that they have been dealing with these issues in ways that are fragmented. If they take an approach that looks at community connections and everyone’s collective roles, they can build a community that supports the health and emotional well-being of all youth in their community.

Section E Identifying Narrative Influencers in the Community

Key Terms Narratives are promoted or advanced by community influencers.

  • Individuals and organizations in a community shape narratives and their underlying frames. It is their values that influence how a community responds to an issue, such as health and well-being.

  • Collective leadership (i.e., how groups work together) can also influence those frames.

  • As frames that underlie narratives are shaped, so too are the stories and messages that result from those frames and circulate among the community.

  • To keep a focus on health equity and collective well-being in a more cohesive health narrative for a community, it is important to connect three things:

    • understanding the frames
    • identifying who is shaping and advancing the frames
    • determining how those frames can be linked to community action for health.
Visual

Recall Figure 2.2. from earlier in the module.

Influencers are key to crafting, driving, and sustaining narratives. Actions are the results of narrative change and can, in turn, influence frames that undergird narratives. Thus, making cultural shifts or changing programs or policy can start to shift or move a community’s health narrative because the influencers shift the frames that underlie the narratives. However, the impact can go the other way as well. For instance, an action (e.g., policy) that a community takes can shift the underlying frames about how the community views an issue. Influencers can take frames forward into action but also can change the frames themselves.

Figure 2.2 The Elements of Narrative
A diagram illustrating the interconnection between three elements: Frames, Influencers, and Actions, under the overarching concept of Elements of Narrative
Source: Adapted from Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, 2022.

Figure Details

A diagram illustrating the interconnection between three elements: Frames, Influencers, and Actions, under the overarching concept of "Elements of Narrative."

  • At the top, a box labeled "Elements of Narrative" leads to a box labeled "Frames." Two arrows descend from "Frames," connecting to two boxes below.
  • On the left, a box labeled "Influencers" lists examples: Individuals, Organizations, and Collective Leadership.
  • On the right, a box labeled "Actions" lists examples: Cultural Shifts, Programmatic Change, and Policy Change. The boxes are all connected by horizontal double-sided arrows, indicating bidirectional interactions between Frames, Influencers, and Actions.
Discussion

Discussion Prompt 2E.8: Mapping Influencers in Your Community

Using insights from other parts of the module in this exercise, discuss the influencers who are shaping your community’s health narrative. Explore which narratives are dominant and why, and consider the following questions:

  • What community features will help maintain and sustain a narrative that promotes health equity and collective well-being? Who will advance this narrative?
  • What might make it difficult to keep the community’s attention on health narratives that strengthen our focus and action on health equity and collective well-being? What might disrupt positive narratives about health equity and/or collective well-being?

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

Spend two to three minutes answering the questions individually using notepads, sticky notes, or the Participant Workbook.

Share perspectives in small groups for 15 minutes. During discussion, write down responses to the first set of questions in one column on an easel pad or in a central location. Write responses to the second set of questions in another column.

Section F Taking Steps Forward on the Health and Well-Being Narrative

It will take some time to digest the concepts and ideas in this module. Developing a coherent, actionable narrative that can serve as your community’s North Star on health and well-being does not happen overnight. This module is intended to help your community take its first steps toward creating a narrative that actively advances health equity and collective well-being. But this work will require a deep consideration of your community’s values and experiences and how those factors tie into perspectives and priorities on health and well-being. These efforts will help to keep moving your narrative forward, maturing it, and then working as a community to advance it.

The next modules begin to unpack other sticking points—data and investment—that are the focus of this toolkit. But know that the issue of narrative will continue to show up in this toolkit. Having a clear narrative is key to knowing which data matter and how to best align investments.

Despite the time it takes to develop a coherent, actionable narrative, your community members can start right now to move their ideas forward. Try out the following discussion prompt before you complete this module. The prompt will take two perspectives, described as the forest and the trees.

Forest
Forest: This perspective focuses on how to express a new health and well-being narrative for your community broadly.
Tree
Trees: This perspective focuses on how to link work on a specific community issue or problem to your health narrative.
Discussion

Discussion Prompt 2F.9: Forest and Trees—Working to Advance the Health and Well-Being Narrative

Before you answer the questions in this prompt, as a group, consider the following concepts from this module:

  • frames: influenced by values, mindsets, and history
  • influencers: individuals, organizations, and collective leadership
  • actions: cultural shifts and program and policy changes.

First, consider what your group would say in the following scenarios if you were advancing a broader health and well-being narrative using these concepts. Remember the focus on health equity and collective well-being.

Forest

If you were mayor for a day and wanted to tell a story about why the health and well-being of your community matters and is a priority, what would you say? What key points could be discussed in a State of the City address or a community message? What is the fresh or new narrative you want to advance about health and well-being? What community values and experiences would you pull from to make the case and share a North Star?

Think about how a mayor would discuss the ability of community members to collaborate during times of stress, like how they talk about local economic indicators.

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

Take ten to fifteen minutes to discuss these questions as a group and capture key points.

Now to the trees: Consider what your group would say if they were trying to link an issue or topic on health (or another area) to the broader narrative about health and well-being. Again, remember the focus on health equity and collective well-being.

Tree

Consider one of the health topics that came up in this module or is a priority health issue for your community (e.g., food access, pandemic response). Then, discuss the following questions:

  • How can that health issue better align with your new health narrative that emphasizes health equity and collective well-being? For example, suppose your community is trying to improve food security for all residents. How can you explain how addressing that issue also helps to strengthen the quality of social connection in the community or collective well-being?
  • What would constitute a narrative win if you better tied that heath topic to a broader community health narrative? For instance, what are examples of community influencers who can link food security to health equity in ways that are understandable and get leaders in the community to take action?
  • What could you do tomorrow, after completing this module, to get community members aligned around that common health and well-being narrative—your North Star? For instance, what could you bring forward into a community meeting or a policy debate?

Facilitator Instructions Facilitator Instructions

Take ten to fifteen minutes to discuss these questions as a group and capture key points.

Section G Ready to Move to the Next Module?

By the end of this second module, you should have discussed the following:

  • what narrative is and why it matters for advancing health and well-being in your community (Section A)
  • the values and beliefs that underlie your community’s views and actions for health and well-being (Section B)
  • the ways that your community’s health narrative can sharpen a focus on health equity and collective well-being specifically (Sections C–F).

If you have a good understanding of these issues in your community, you are ready to move to the next module—Module 3, Measuring for Action. If not, you can revisit the sections of this module and the corresponding exercises to deepen your insight.

Reminder Reminder

After completing this module, document your key takeaways and action items. There is a place to do this in the Participant Workbook.

For feedback on this toolkit and to share how you are using it in your community, please send an email to:

ALIGN@rand.org