- actions
- In the context of these workshops, the results of narrative change, such as cultural shifts, policy changes, and program changes
- catalytic measures
-
Measures that do one or more of the following actions:
- help set goals (near-term and adaptable versus long-term)
- frame issues (e.g., health and well-being are about more than health care)
- create common terms to help individuals and organizations see a commonality of interests
- shift venues (e.g. change how and where an issue is framed and discussed)
These measures often can be used as sentinel indicators of community health and well-being to map to the community health narrative North Star.
- culture
- Sharing and alignment of beliefs, attitudes, values, and actions across a set of individuals, organizations, and decision environments (e.g., where policies or laws are made)
- data
- Any facts, statistics, or inputs used for analysis that come from multiple sources, including administrative files and records, encounters, interviews, focus groups, social interactions, or social media
- experiences
- Events or encounters related to lived or personal experiences and/or current events or experiences in a community
- indicator
- A specified percentage, number, or amount of something to be measured (e.g., number of people with cancer, percentage of a budget that goes to parks)
- influencers
- Individuals, organizations, or collective leadership that lead or provoke health conversations, shape stories about health, and/or set the priorities for health in a population or community
- investments
- The allocation of community resources, which include financial resources, community policies, and time dedicated by community leaders
- equity
-
Includes
- procedural equity: the perceived fairness of processes and procedures in decisionmaking
- contextual equity: how preexisting social conditions influence equity
- distributive equity: how social welfare and need is balanced
In some community contexts, the word equity might not be useful or desirable. Here are some options for terms that could help keep the conversation going:
- health opportunities
- social contexts around health
- fairness in health
- health for all
- health choices
- frames
- Underlying values and beliefs about what influences outcomes (e.g., health outcomes)
- health equity
- The fair and just access to the opportunity to be healthy for all
- measure
- A way of categorizing something to assess, track, or understand it (e.g., positive mental health, health care investments)
- messages
- The articulation of the narrative frame that serves as the strategic foundation for storytelling
- mindsets
- Ways that individuals and groups think about a topic, such as health and well-being
- narrative
-
The critical frames and resulting stories and messaging that influence and inform the way people and communities see and describe the world
A narrative helps to articulate a way of understanding the world and informs how people then act.
- performance-based measures
-
Measures that are focused on accountability and linked to rewards and punishments
These measures tend to be most useful to track a department’s or organization’s effectiveness.
- stories
-
Accounts of experiences via oral or written tradition
Narratives can represent the aggregation of stories that we see, hear, and experience.
- values
- Individual and community principles or standards of behavior
- well-being
-
The full range of assets and capabilities that people need to thrive and create meaningful futures
Well-being is multifaceted and includes
- individual well-being: the state in which people experience happiness and satisfaction and can realize their full potential
- community well-being: the combination of social, economic, environmental, cultural, and political conditions identified by individuals, families, and their communities as essential for them to flourish and fulfill their potential
- collective well-being: the expression of the connections between individual and community well-being. When communities (e.g., places or cultures) are characterized by a strong collective well-being, they have the collective will and connected experiences that allow community members to work together to address systemic harms and build a future together. For instance, collective well-being can refer to the strength and quality of connections among people, between people and institutions in the community, and between people and nature.
Throughout each module, we include these key features with corresponding icons to enhance your understanding and to guide action.
Module 4 Connecting Intention to Action
Aligning Investments for Health Equity and Collective Well-Being
What Is in This Module?
This module focuses on aligning investments and resources (hereafter referred to only as investments)—such as community budgets, policies, and leaders’ time—with a health and well-being narrative that emphasizes health equity and collective well-being. This module will guide your community in reviewing its strategic plans, community development plans, budgets, and other documents that represent how your community prioritizes and invests. The goal is to identify opportunities for better alignment and to find ways to solve for any points of disconnect among and between community plans, with a particular focus on gaps, redundancies, and opportunities for investments that offer multiple benefits for health and well-being.
As described later in this module, investment alignment is the way that communities connect their intentions (e.g., the health and well-being narrative) to the outcomes a community wants to achieve. Sometimes, communities have good intentions in their plans, but a closer inspection of the choices that appear in their budgets and plans reveals that the choices do not match those intentions or help to achieve them. This module is aimed at addressing these misalignments and exploring the question: How do you allocate investments more directly toward the things you have said matter to your community with regard to health and well-being?
We recommend that you complete this module after reviewing prior modules (particularly Module 1, Making the Case, and Module 2, Walking the Talk) because the North Star narrative for health and well-being that you develop for your community in those modules informs both your choice of investments and decisions about what those investments should be aligned to.
As a reminder, definitions of terms such as health equity and collective well-being are in the glossary. As described in the Introduction, these two terms are the pillars of each toolkit module.
Talking Points
Use this module to invite leaders in your community into conversations about health and well-being investments. See the Introduction if you are unsure about which leaders to include. As with other modules in this toolkit, this module includes new concepts, discussion prompts, and group exercises. It can be facilitated by a group leader or worked on collaboratively in a group setting.
Facilitator Instructions
- A computer or mobile device (if using the digital toolkit)
- A whiteboard or large easel pad in a central location for group exercises
- Easel pads for each small group
- Markers (enough for each small group)
- Printouts of the resources provided at the end of the toolkit (e.g., Participant Workbook, glossary) to provide as handouts; printouts of module pages for those who do not have a computer or mobile device
- Optional sticky notes or notepads for individual brainstorming
- Pens, markers, and paper for notetaking, if preferred
For some of the exercises in this module, you also will need a community document or set of materials that include these features:
- a vision for the community’s future (e.g., master plan for the community)
- details on goals, objectives, and/or priority areas for action on behalf of the entire community (e.g., materials from the mayor, city council, or an agency charged with writing a plan for the community).
You will also want copies of your organization’s budget and strategic plan.
Skills Acquired to Connect Intention to Action
By the end of this module, Connecting Intention to Action, your community will be able to
- identify areas of alignment and disconnection between health and well-being ambitions and current investments
- determine why some of the misalignment might exist and how to act on opportunities to address it
- develop a stronger rationale for why alignment within and across community plans can benefit health and well-being, particularly health equity and collective well-being.
Organization of This Module
This module proceeds in four sections that build on each other:
Appendix B in the annex to this toolkit explains the orienting principles that inform the design of this module.
Section A Using the Narrative from Prior Modules
Take a few minutes to revisit the concept of narrative from Module 2 or the glossary. If you have not identified your community’s narrative on health and well-being, you can use (or continue to use) the narrative example provided in the next talking points section.
Key Terms
- Narratives provide a “North Star” (i.e., a source of direction) to guide action.
- Narrative offers the ability to
- mobilize a community toward a common aspiration or goal
- connect disparate efforts to align on overarching messages and stories
- emotionally and practically anchor a vision of health progress.
Section B Examining Key Investment Principles
In this section, we will dive deeper into the key principles of investment and investment alignment.
Key Terms
Community investments include budget allocations, policy designs and implementations, and partnership choices.
In this module, we invite you to think about investments in the following ways:
- Community budgets are generally driven by government investments of tax dollars and the receipt of external grants from philanthropy or state and federal sources.
- Investments in community health can come from government sources, but they also include choices made by nongovernmental actors, such as businesses and philanthropies.
- Nonmonetary investments also matter. These include the time provided by community organizations to achieve or provide health and well-being initiatives and services, time that might take the form of volunteer capacity (Kranz et al., 2021).
Key Terms
An organization’s budgets can demonstrate how investments are aligned and help the community understand whether the organization is moving in the direction of health equity and collective well-being. It is important to review an organization’s budget line items and organizational priorities as articulated in its strategic plan because these choices influence the overall community’s investment portfolio in health and well-being. These same principles apply to a community-wide budget or strategic plan.
Diagnosing Health Equity Investments
Use the checklist in the Participant Workbook to assess the programs, initiatives, and/or line items in your budget and broader investment portfolio. For each, determine whether the effort
- directly contributes to making your community more equitable (e.g., a housing program that helps first-time homebuyers)
- indirectly contributes to making your community more equitable (e.g., a transportation program that helps people access health care)
- has no effect on inequities in your community
- increases inequity in your community (e.g., an infrastructure choice that might make it more difficult for residents to engage with residents from other neighborhoods).
Diagnosing Collective Well-Being Investments
Use the checklist in the Participant Workbook to assess the programs, initiatives, and/or line items in your budget and broader investment portfolio. For each, determine whether the effort
- directly contributes to collective well-being in your community (e.g., a program that connects children and adults to participate in intergenerational learning)
- indirectly contributes to collective well-being in your community (e.g., a sports program that not only entertains but also has the secondary benefit of building trust in the community)
- has no effect on collective well-being in your community
- decreases collective well-being in your community (e.g., an infrastructure choice that makes it harder for people to connect to nature).
Facilitator Instructions
Instructions: Allow five minutes for participants to fill in the tables in the Participant Workbook with a set of organizational investment choices. Ask participants to share one or two examples and their ratings from their organization’s budget or strategic plan. Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.
Refer to the glossary if you need to brush up on terms, but here is a refresher on important terms for this exercise:
- Collective well-being refers to the connections between individual and community well-being (e.g., connections among people, between people and institutions in the community, and between people and nature). Collective well-being is addressed through investments that help people thrive in their communities, feel positive about their futures, and experience positive health not just the absence of disease.
- Health equity means that everyone in the community has fair and just access to the opportunity to be healthy. Health equity is addressed through services, supports, investments, and policies that support this comprehensive goal.
In your small groups, identify objectives in the report that do not explicitly focus on health. For example, in an Anytown 2030 plan, this could be objectives such as “strengthen economic development,” “retain and build the workforce,” or “enhance community safety.” Select two of those objectives and identify ways that you could better frame them to connect more explicitly to health equity and collective well-being. For each objective, consider the following questions:
- How will this reframed objective center and affect health equity? For instance, how will the objective or a proposed action in the plan help improve health outcomes for everyone? How will it provide better access to services for everyone?
- How can this reframed objective positively affect collective well-being? For instance, how is it supporting better connections among different groups in the community?
- How might your reframing of the objective help others see themselves as having a role to advance it? For instance, could a health objective make a clear argument for why health matters for economic development (e.g., a healthier workforce can attract employers to the region)? Or could a transportation objective demonstrate how it benefits health equity and/or collective well-being in the community (e.g., building roads to connect neighborhoods can result in more exchanges across neighborhoods)?
Facilitator Instructions
We advise forming small groups of no more than six people. To ensure robust discussion, groups should reflect different perspectives and community sectors.
Groups should take ten to fifteen minutes to discuss these questions. There are fields in the Participant Workbook to write down answers, but each group should also use an easel pad and markers to document their work. Afterward, reconvene to share back as a larger group.
Here are some additional questions you can pose to the group during discussion:
- What is our community doing well in our investment strategy that will benefit health equity and/or collective well-being?
- What could we be doing better?
Key Terms
Given that community resources are often limited or stretched, finding opportunities to produce multiple benefits from a single investment choice is key. For health equity, investment choices that benefit public safety or infrastructure quality can also yield benefits to health equity. For collective well-being, investment choices that enhance quality of life, support people’s connection to nature, and/or enhance social connections are valued. For instance, the design of a park can mean more than additional green space or recreation; its features could also promote collective well-being.
There are a few types of investment strategies, including
- braiding: sharing or pooling resources to increase impacts on health equity and collective well-being
- linking: strengthening coordination and partnerships around a connected set of investments that enhance health equity and collective well-being
- shedding: revising or sunsetting investments that do not align with a community’s health equity and collective well-being narrative and do not produce multiple benefits to that end
- shifting: moving investments to ensure that they are effectively implemented to realize health equity and collective well-being benefits
Shedding and Shifting Strategies
If you were to assess items within your organization’s broader investment portfolio, how would you describe its opportunities for shedding and shifting?
Pick an example or two from your organization and fill in the checklist in the Participant Workbook. For each, determine whether
- this item has benefits for both our division or organization and the community. It also has benefits for health equity and/or collective well-being.
- the community benefits from this item, but our division or organization does not.
- our division or organization benefits from this item, but the community does not.
- neither the community nor our division or organization benefits from this item.
Note that this prompt is not meant to have you rate all of your organization’s activities or summarize them with a score. Rather, this checklist is to help motivate your organization to examine how you could budget differently and gain efficiencies to support health and well-being.
Facilitator Instructions
Allow individuals five to ten minutes to fill in their set of organizational investment choices in the tables in the Participant Workbook. Participants can also use this time to connect with other organizations in the room to discuss these strategies.
Afterward, share perspectives from around the room for ten to fifteen minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.
To explore how your organization upholds this principle, consider the following questions
- How does your organization perform when it comes to making investments that produce multiple benefits?
- Are you advancing health equity and/or collective well-being in what your organization prioritizes? Could these efforts be linked to the activities of other organizations or departments?
- Which of the four alignment strategies (braiding, linking, shedding, and shifting) could your organization use?
The goal of these questions is to invite you to briefly review the multiple benefits investment principle in the context of your organization before you try it out in a community-wide exercise in Section C.
Key Terms
Many health departments are disproportionately funded by external grants. Given that many of the drivers of health equity and collective well-being lie outside traditional health services and systems (see Module 1), there are opportunities to better link investments in health and well-being with multiple funding sources (e.g., youth programs, infrastructure investments). Even with frameworks, such as Health in All Policies, active approaches to this kind of investment consideration remain limited for many communities (Kranz et al., 2021).
Facilitator Instructions
Allow individuals five minutes to fill in their set of organizational investment choices in the tables in the Participant Workbook.
Afterward, share perspectives from around the room for ten to fifteen minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.
Section C Applying Principles to Community Investment Plans
The rest of this module is about exercising these three investment principles.
For the next exercise, you will need to use the sample budget from two government departments in an unnamed community provided in the Participant Workbook.
We provide these hypothetical documents to help you work with important concepts before addressing potential sensitivities while reviewing your community’s budget as a group. However, if you prefer, you can use your community’s budget documents. If you do this, start with no more than two government departments.
Facilitator Instructions
In small groups of no more than six people, take 20 minutes to review the hypothetical budget tables in the Participant Workbook. There are fields in the Participant Workbook to write down answers to these questions, but groups should also use easel pads and markers to document their work.
Here are some additional questions you can pose to the group during discussion:
- What ideas did you have for fostering connections? Why did you pick those? How do those ideas better help efforts toward health equity and/or collective well-being?
- Did you see items that seemed duplicative or that could create inefficiencies for addressing your community’s health and well-being narrative?
Facilitator Instructions
To wrap up this module and plan ahead, spend ten to fifteen minutes discussing these questions. Make sure to take notes or write ideas on a large easel pad, poster board, or in a central location because doing so will help you continue the work after you complete this toolkit. Ensure that different voices and sectors (e.g., not just the health department) are heard during this discussion, particularly as you try to identify different policy and investment choices.
Section D Ready to Move to the Next Module?
By the end of this fourth module, you should have discussed the following:
- emerging narratives to advance health equity and collective well-being in your community as a foundation to this module (Section A)
- key principles of investment and investment alignment and how to develop a stronger rationale for why alignment within and across community plans has a benefit to health and well-being, particularly health equity and collective well-being (Section B)
- areas of alignment and disconnection between health and well-being ambitions and current investments, as well as opportunities to enhance alignment (Section C).
If you have a good understanding of these issues in your community, you are ready to move to the next module—Module 5, Taking Action. If not, you can revisit the sections of this module and the corresponding exercises to deepen your insight.
Reminder
After completing this module, document your key takeaways and action items. There is a place to do this in the Participant Workbook.
For feedback on this toolkit and to share how you are using it in your community, please send an email to: