- actions
- In the context of these workshops, the results of narrative change, such as cultural shifts, policy changes, and program changes
- catalytic measures
-
Measures that do one or more of the following actions:
- help set goals (near-term and adaptable versus long-term)
- frame issues (e.g., health and well-being are about more than health care)
- create common terms to help individuals and organizations see a commonality of interests
- shift venues (e.g. change how and where an issue is framed and discussed)
These measures often can be used as sentinel indicators of community health and well-being to map to the community health narrative North Star.
- culture
- Sharing and alignment of beliefs, attitudes, values, and actions across a set of individuals, organizations, and decision environments (e.g., where policies or laws are made)
- data
- Any facts, statistics, or inputs used for analysis that come from multiple sources, including administrative files and records, encounters, interviews, focus groups, social interactions, or social media
- experiences
- Events or encounters related to lived or personal experiences and/or current events or experiences in a community
- indicator
- A specified percentage, number, or amount of something to be measured (e.g., number of people with cancer, percentage of a budget that goes to parks)
- influencers
- Individuals, organizations, or collective leadership that lead or provoke health conversations, shape stories about health, and/or set the priorities for health in a population or community
- investments
- The allocation of community resources, which include financial resources, community policies, and time dedicated by community leaders
- equity
-
Includes
- procedural equity: the perceived fairness of processes and procedures in decisionmaking
- contextual equity: how preexisting social conditions influence equity
- distributive equity: how social welfare and need is balanced
In some community contexts, the word equity might not be useful or desirable. Here are some options for terms that could help keep the conversation going:
- health opportunities
- social contexts around health
- fairness in health
- health for all
- health choices
- frames
- Underlying values and beliefs about what influences outcomes (e.g., health outcomes)
- health equity
- The fair and just access to the opportunity to be healthy for all
- measure
- A way of categorizing something to assess, track, or understand it (e.g., positive mental health, health care investments)
- messages
- The articulation of the narrative frame that serves as the strategic foundation for storytelling
- mindsets
- Ways that individuals and groups think about a topic, such as health and well-being
- narrative
-
The critical frames and resulting stories and messaging that influence and inform the way people and communities see and describe the world
A narrative helps to articulate a way of understanding the world and informs how people then act.
- performance-based measures
-
Measures that are focused on accountability and linked to rewards and punishments
These measures tend to be most useful to track a department’s or organization’s effectiveness.
- stories
-
Accounts of experiences via oral or written tradition
Narratives can represent the aggregation of stories that we see, hear, and experience.
- values
- Individual and community principles or standards of behavior
- well-being
-
The full range of assets and capabilities that people need to thrive and create meaningful futures
Well-being is multifaceted and includes
- individual well-being: the state in which people experience happiness and satisfaction and can realize their full potential
- community well-being: the combination of social, economic, environmental, cultural, and political conditions identified by individuals, families, and their communities as essential for them to flourish and fulfill their potential
- collective well-being: the expression of the connections between individual and community well-being. When communities (e.g., places or cultures) are characterized by a strong collective well-being, they have the collective will and connected experiences that allow community members to work together to address systemic harms and build a future together. For instance, collective well-being can refer to the strength and quality of connections among people, between people and institutions in the community, and between people and nature.
Throughout each module, we include these key features with corresponding icons to enhance your understanding and to guide action.
Module 3 Measuring for Action
Promoting Data for Health Equity and Collective Well-Being
What Is in This Module?
This module focuses on how to measure progress in health and well-being, with the intention of selecting and acting on data that can catalyze action. The module will guide your community to review data that you use to gain information on health and well-being, assess how well these data provide information on health equity and collective well-being, and determine what could be done to better select and use data to guide community action for health. As described later in this module, selecting the right measures is key to helping a community focus its efforts and allocate its resources. By doing so, communities can get ahead of emerging health concerns and use data to not only track morbidity and mortality but also capture information about positive health and well-being.
We recommend that you complete this module after working through prior modules (Module 1, Making the Case, and Module 2, Walking the Talk) because understanding gaps in community health and identifying your community’s ultimate North Star for health and well-being will inform your choices about which measures and data are important to your community.
As a reminder, definitions of terms such as health equity and collective well-being are in the glossary. As described in the Introduction, these two terms are the pillars of each toolkit module.
Use this module to invite leaders in your community into conversations about health and well-being measures and data. See the Introduction if you are unsure about which leaders to include. As with other modules in this toolkit, this module includes new concepts, discussion prompts, and group exercises. It can be facilitated by a group leader or worked on collaboratively in a group setting.
Facilitator Instructions
- A computer or mobile device (if using the digital toolkit)
- A whiteboard or large easel pad in a central location for group exercises
- Easel pads for each small group
- Markers (enough for each small group)
- Printouts of the resources provided at the end of the toolkit (e.g., Participant Workbook, glossary) to provide as handouts; printouts of module pages for those who do not have a computer or mobile device
- Optional sticky notes or notepads for individual brainstorming
- Pens, markers, and paper for notetaking, if preferred
Additionally, for some of the exercises in this module, you will need a community document or similar set of materials, such as a report from your health sector. This document can be a community health needs assessment (ideally) or any report that shows data from the public health department, health system, or the like. The report or reports must have information on health disparities, quality of life in the community, and related health and well-being data. The document should include some information that is not simply about disease tracking but also about other social factors, such as transportation or housing.
Skills Acquired to Measure for Action
By the end of this module, Measuring for Action, your community will be able to
- characterize the kind of data that your community is collecting on health and well-being, including health equity
- identify what measures and associated data are needed to better capture information about health equity and collective well-being
- identify ways to strengthen your community’s data system, including analyzing what types of data you gather, how you link data across sectors and organizations in your community, and how you translate and use that data to guide community dialogue and action.
Organization of This Module
This module proceeds in four sections that build on each other:
Appendix B in the annex to this toolkit explains the orienting principles that inform the design of this module.
Section A Refreshing Narrative
Take a few minutes to revisit the concept of narrative from Module 2 or the glossary and then consider what your community’s narrative on health and well-being could be, especially one that includes a greater emphasis on health equity and collective well-being. This narrative will inform the exercises in this module, and you will explore whether your community’s data fit that narrative.
Key Terms
Facilitator Instructions
Spend two to three minutes answering the questions individually using notepads, sticky notes, or the Participant Workbook. Have participants post their answers on a large poster board or in a central location.
Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.
To begin the discussion, pose the following questions:
- What came up as your organization’s narrative for health and well-being?
- How does that narrative connect to your community’s narrative or North Star?
Talking Points
If your community has not yet identified a health and well-being narrative, you can use the following example to guide your discussions in the rest of the module. Ideally, your community members will use a narrative that they have crafted for themselves, but sometimes crafting a new narrative can take more time than is available.
“We value the ability of everyone to provide for their families and support each other in this community. We make choices that promote health and enable people to grow and prepare for what’s ahead.”
Section B Examining Key Data Principles
In this section, we will dive deeper into the key principles of data that can be used to catalyze community action. The goals of the rest of this module are to help your community better use data to achieve action, to review what your community is measuring, to analyze whether those data and measures are serving the needs of proactive community planning, and to identify areas where your community can strengthen how it is assessing health equity and collective well-being specifically.
Before diving in, try out this discussion prompt.
Facilitator Instructions
Spend two to three minutes answering the questions individually using notepads, sticky notes, or the Participant Workbook. Have participants post their answers on a large poster board or in a central location.
Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.
During the discussion, pose the following questions:
- As you listen to each other’s answers, are there common data points?
- If yes, why do you think that is?
Key Terms
- Any data that can be used to understand, assess, and monitor the
health and well-being of a community, population, and/or nation with
the purpose of
- looking ahead or prospectively determining health assets and needs (e.g., asking such questions as, “Are we investing in children to help them thrive as they get older?”)
- looking back or retrospectively capturing intergenerational trajectories of health over time (e.g., asking such questions as, “What policies and structures made it difficult for the generations that came before us to be healthy?”).
- Data that can speak to health and well-being do not just come from health agencies, such as the public health department or health care organizations; they can come from a variety of sources.
Key Terms
Modern health and well-being data should have a greater focus on positive health and well-being. This means data that do not simply capture information about mortality, morbidity, or disease management but also
- capture such factors as subjective well-being (e.g., hope, optimism)
- capture community investments to support thriving (e.g., investments in community assets that support social connection).
Health and well-being data should include information on both individual well-being (e.g., personal experiences of thriving) and collective well-being (e.g., levels of social connection). Additionally, health and well-being data should help communities proactively understand the “pulse” (or the sentiments) of the community (e.g., data on how residents feel about the health of the community or how things are going in the community via survey or social media).
To gain a better understanding of what these data might look like, Table 3.1 provides examples of individual well-being measures, and Table 3.2 provides examples of collective well-being measures.
| Example | Example Indicator | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Life satisfaction: a subjective measure of individual well-being | The percentage of the population who report being satisfied or very satisfied with their lives | Johnson et al., 2019 |
| Positive affect: the extent to which an individual experiences pleasurable emotions and moods | The percentage of the population who report experiencing enjoyment and happiness during a lot of the day | Gallup, 2021 |
| Sense of purpose: the feeling of having meaningful goals and direction in life, which contribute to motivation and fulfillment | The percentage of the population who report liking what they do every day | Gallup, 2021 |
| Social support: the perceived availability and quality of emotional, informational, and practical assistance received from one’s social network | The percentage of the population who report getting the emotional and social support that they need | Johnson et al., 2019 |
| Future thriving: the anticipation of achieving personal and professional growth, fulfillment, and well-being in the coming years | The percentage of the population who report a positive five-year outlook using the Cantril Self-Anchoring Striving Scale | Wello, 2024 |
| Example | Example Indicator | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Neighbors, neighborliness, and neighborhood cohesion: residents feel a sense of belonging or social connectedness in their neighborhood | The proportion of residents who know their neighbors and regularly engage with them | Civic Wellbeing Partners, undated |
| Connection through groups: connections through spiritual groups, volunteer groups, neighborhood councils, and other groups | The proportion of people who report that they have the opportunity to make social connections through at least one formal group | Civic Wellbeing Partners, undated |
| Proximity to and distribution of amenities and services that boost well-being: the number and accessibility of resources that promote physical, mental, and social well-being within a community, which could include access to health care facilities, parks and green spaces, healthy food options, community centers, and public transportation | The number of parks, community centers, and grocery stores per capita within a specific geographic area, such as a neighborhood or census tract | Civic Wellbeing Partners, undated |
| Pride in place: residents feel a sense of pride and attachment to their community or neighborhood, including their perceptions of the community, having a sense of belonging, and showing a willingness to invest their time and resources into improving their neighborhoods | The proportion of residents who express a feeling of pride and emotional connection to their community or neighborhood | Civic Wellbeing Partners, undated |
| Availability of arts and culture activities: the number and accessibility of resources that promote cultural engagement and artistic expression within a community | The number of arts and culture activities per capita within a specific geographic area, such as a neighborhood or census tract | Civic Wellbeing Partners, undated |
| Opportunities for kids and families to stay and grow in their community: the availability and accessibility of resources that support child and family well-being within a community, which could include access to quality childcare, early childhood education, after-school programs, and youth sports leagues | The number of after-school programs per capita within a specific geographic area, such as a neighborhood or census tract | Civic Wellbeing Partners, undated |
Facilitator Instructions
Allow time for participants to note ideas in their Participant Workbook. Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.
Using the examples provided as a reference, explore how participants’ suggestions might touch on elements of collective well-being (e.g., connections between people and places, investments in the community) and/or how they could be modified to better paint a picture of these elements.
Key Terms
Orienting toward equity refers to the extent to which the data that the community is tracking and prioritizing reflects equity (and not simply disparities). (See the glossary for definitions of equity.) Consider the types of data that your community is collecting and whether those data examine such topics as structure and policies and not simply the gaps in outcomes between groups.
The failure to consider different types of equity in data can create challenges for a community. In addition to the equity examples from before, it is important to consider whether you have data that account for different types of equity, such as the following:
- Procedural equity
Is your community tracking information in a way that ensures that there is a fair process by which health decisions are being made? And is there a way for community members to be involved in decisions about what health data are prioritized?
For example, are you aware of any written procedures on how to provide input on health decisions in the community, and do you have data on who participates? Are there data on citizen assemblies or other forums in which people can have their thoughts and opinions about health in the community heard?
Without a focus on procedural equity, public engagement processes might seem performative or pointless, and community trust can be damaged. - Contextual equity
Is context provided when data are presented?
For example, are there data on historical policies (e.g., residential policies, instances in which economic investment was or was not provided) that could be informing current community health outcomes?
Without considering contextual equity, data could be misinterpreted or might reinforce inequities. For instance, sometimes when disparities data are presented without context, certain groups are blamed for those disparities. - Distributional equity
Are the data arrayed in a way that can inform necessary choices that balance social welfare and need? Are the data organized to look at multiple factors together to drive better decisionmaking?
For example, are indicators, such as educational and health investments, put together to tell a story of child health and well-being?
Without a focus on distributional equity, it is difficult to use data to make policy choices that balance possible trade-offs.
Table 3.3 provides some examples of equity measures that primarily reflect contextual and procedural elements.
| Example | Example Indicator | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Depth and diversity of community-based organizations: assess the representation of community-based organizations for various groups in the community | The proportion of community-based organizations that represent various groups in the community and include categories such as race, ethnicity, gender, age, and socioeconomic status | Chandra et al., 2018 |
| Historical legacy and the context of policies or programs: document past disparities and grievances through historical accounts, ethnographic study, community discussions, and qualitative data collection to estimate the number of households or individuals affected by these disparities and the types of impacts these disparities had to gain a comprehensive understanding of the root causes of the disparities | The number of households affected by discriminatory housing policies resulting in a loss of generational wealth | Martín and Lewis, 2019 |
| Community involvement in policy development: assess whether opportunities for substantive community input are provided throughout the policy process | The percentage of stages of a given policy process during which community input is sought | ChangeLab Solutions, undated |
| Equitable access to services and programs: assess marketing and outreach activities and qualitatively assess access procedures and materials to uncover potential barriers | A comparison of the proportion of applications and approvals for a program with those in the general population | Martín and Lewis, 2019 |
| Residential segregation: assess the overlap between residential segregation and the experience of harms and assets | The percentage of the population living within one-half mile of a park in neighborhoods with different racial and ethnic compositions | U.S. Census Bureau, undated |
| Environmental exposures: examine the distribution of exposure to hazards | Legacy pollution (i.e., proximity to hazardous waste sites) and projected exposure to climate hazards, such as future flooding, building losses, and future wildfires | Climate Program Portal, 2025 |
Facilitator Instructions
Allow time for participants to note ideas in their Participant Workbook. Share perspectives from around the room for five to ten minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.
Using the examples provided as a reference, explore how participant suggestions might touch on the different elements (contextual, procedural, distributional) of equity and push back on examples that are focused only on disparities or differences between groups.
Key Terms
Many communities have a deluge of data and report that they cannot use so many data points to inform decisions. For instance, a community might have a lot of information about the nuances of a particular program’s performance or a list of disease indicators. These data might be useful for certain government departments, but they are often not useful to tell a story of health and well-being and to pinpoint where to act.
The existence of data does not automatically mean such data are being translated into actionable information. Even when data are converted into actionable information, they must be contextualized to ensure they make sense for a community. For instance, many communities have data dashboards and scorecards, but when some community leaders or organizations access these data, it can be hard for them to make sense of lots of numbers and to know where to focus their attention.
Key Terms
See the glossary for a definition of catalytic measures.
Some data (e.g., catalytic data) can be used to motivate a broader group, whereas other data are more useful for individual agencies or organizations to conduct internal performance monitoring. It is important to distinguish between these types of data to effectively motivate community action.
Catalytic data can help in many ways and well beyond performance measures. Catalytic measures can be used to address one or more of these aims:
- Setting adaptable and shorter-term community goals rather than those that are harder to change and take longer to realize. An example would be tracking affordable housing, which involves data that can change in a year, rather than socioeconomic status or poverty levels, which do not often improve or change rapidly. Addressing this aim helps to ensure that progress is visible, which encourages more action and a stronger commitment to health and well-being.
- Framing issues that are important for the community rather than using jargon, such as social determinants of health, to, for example, capture how people value environmental factors that influence health. It is important to use plain language while collecting and discussing these measurements.
- Creating common terms, for example, using terms such as adverse and positive childhood experiences allows more sectors to engage because everyone has a stake in the well-being of children versus using terms such as depression rates that might be seen as important by only the health sector.
- Shifting venues for health action, for example, by finding a measure that links health to the distribution of libraries. Such a measure could show how community environmental factors make a difference in the community’s health and does not locate health concerns only in the doctor’s office.
Here are a few more examples of the difference between a performance-based vs. catalytic measure:
- A performance-based measure is the number of people served by a health program. A catalytic measure is the level of investment in programs that promote positive health and well-being. The latter not only provides information on how well the community is reorienting its focus away from health investments that only address disease but also shows a priority on positive health programming in the language of the measures.
- A performance-based measure is one that often is lagging, such as the number of people living in poverty. A catalytic measure might be the investment in predistribution economic measures, such as the level of household supports available when a child is born (Nelson, Chandra, and Miller, 2018).
Figure Details
A diagram illustrating a pyramid structure titled "Saying more with less: The public and decisionmakers often need only a subset of data to act." The pyramid, labeled “Comprehensive data”, consists of three levels.
- At the top, labeled "Sentinel indicators of community health and well-being," there is a description that states “Data (often catalytic) that best aligns with the north star of your community’s health and well-being narrative”.
- The middle section is labeled "Progress indicators of community action and investment," with a description that states “Data that offers information about community improvements to evaluate actions across departments.”
- The bottom level is labeled "Performance indicators of organization- or department-level efforts," with a description that states “Data that give detailed information about the inputs and outputs of organization work.”
To the left of the pyramid, an orange box states “Do not be afraid to “Marie Kondo” your data (i.e., discard the data that do not serve your purposes and organize what remains in a useful way)”, promoting the idea of decluttering data to focus on what truly matters.

Section C Applying Data Principles to Community Data
The rest of this module is about exercising these four data principles. For this final section, you will need a community document or a set of materials, such as a report from your health sector (ideally, a community health needs assessment) or any report that includes data from the public health department, the health system, or another health-related agency. Additionally, these materials must have information on health disparities, quality of life in the community, and other health and well-being data. These materials should also include some information that is not simply about tracking disease but also about other social factors, such as transportation or housing.
Facilitator Instructions
We advise forming small groups of no more than six people. To ensure robust discussion, groups should reflect different perspectives and community sectors.
Groups should take ten to fifteen minutes to discuss before reconvening to share back as a larger group.
Here are some questions you can pose to the group during discussion:
- What did you identify in the community document that would help your community better understand and act on health equity and collective well-being?
- Reflect on whether the different types of equity (contextual, procedural, and distributional) are reflected in the health data or whether the focus is on one specific type.
- Reflect on whether collective well-being is reflected in nonhealth data or whether other elements (individual or community well-being) are the focus.
- What were some of the missing data or information gaps? Are there data you would prioritize? Would you remove some data in favor of a different measure that could better capture information about health equity and collective well-being?
Facilitator Instructions
Spend five to ten minutes answering the questions individually using notepads, sticky notes, or the Participant Workbook. (Sticky notes work particularly well for this activity!) Have participants post their answers on a large poster board or in a central location. As participants bring up ideas for measures, organize the sticky notes into similar categories or domains, if useful.
Share perspectives from around the room for ten to fifteen minutes (depending on group size), ensuring that different voices and sectors are heard.
During the discussion, pose the following questions:
- Can you identify any common measures among what was shared?
- Why did you identify the measures that you did?
- Do we have data for those measures in our community yet?
- If not, what would need to happen to get there?
Section D Ready to Move to the Next Module?
By the end of this third module, you should have discussed the following:
- emerging narratives to advance health equity and collective well-being in your community, even if they will take more time to solidify (Section A)
- what information your community is collecting on health and well-being, including health equity (Section B)
- what measures and associated data are needed to better capture information about health equity and collective well-being that would align with your community’s narrative (Section B)
- ways to strengthen your community’s data system (Section C).
If you have a good understanding of these issues in your community, you are ready to move to the next module—Module 4, Connecting Intention to Action. If not, you can revisit the sections of this module and the corresponding exercises to deepen your insight.
Reminder
After completing this module, document your key takeaways and action items. There is a place to do this in the Participant Workbook.
For feedback on this toolkit and to share how you are using it in your community, please send an email to: