Employers paid 2.5 times what Medicare would have paid for hospital services in 2022
Photo by AdShooter/Getty Images
Overview
In Round 5 of the Hospital Price Transparency Study, RAND researchers analyzed $77.4 billion in hospital spending from more than 4,000 hospitals nationwide, using data from 12 state All-Payer Claims Databases (APCDs) and self-insured employers.
Employers and private insurers paid about 2.5 times what Medicare would have paid
Across all hospital inpatient and outpatient services (including both facility and related professional claims), employers and private insurers paid on average 254 percent of what Medicare would have paid for the same services at the same facilities in 2022.
Inpatient hospital facility services averaged 254% of Medicare prices
Outpatient hospital facility services averaged 279% of Medicare prices
All associated professional services (inpatient plus outpatient) averaged 184% of Medicare prices
Wide variation across states
Lowest-Priced States (Below 200% of Medicare):
Arkansas — Only state below 170% of Medicare
Massachusetts
Michigan
Mississippi
Rhode Island
Highest-Priced States (Above 300% of Medicare):
California
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
New York
South Carolina
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Note: Washington's relative prices appeared significantly lower in Round 4 due to Medicare Advantage claims erroneously included in the APCD data. This has been corrected in Round 5.
Hospital market power drives price variation
Most variation in prices is explained by hospital market power. Very little is explained by each hospital's share of patients covered by Medicare or Medicaid.
Prices have remained stable over time
State-level median prices have held steady at approximately 2.5 times higher than Medicare across study rounds:
Round 3 (2018): 254% of Medicare
Round 4 (2020): 246% of Medicare
Round 5 (2022): 253% of Medicare
Additional findings
Round 5 also examined prices for ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs) and physician-administered drugs. Detailed findings are available in the full report.
Implications for Employers
To increase the value of the health care they pay for, employers could consider:
Changing network and benefit designs to encourage patients to use lower-priced, higher-value providers (where provider quality and convenience are comparable)
Monitoring how contracts are negotiated on their behalf
Exerting pressure on health plans and hospitals to shift from discounted charge contracts to other forms of contracting that limit price variability
Supporting the development and maintenance of APCDs
Requesting state or federal policy changes to strengthen health plans' leverage in negotiating with hospitals