Results You Can Use

A newsletter from PAF's WDH program at RAND

October 2022

I am pleased to share the latest issue of Results You Can Use, a quarterly newsletter featuring research that enables the Department of the Air Force (DAF) to manage its most important asset: its workforce.

One workforce issue I’ve been thinking about lately is the popular belief that the generations differ in behaviors and attitudes. But research suggests that these differences are illusory. For example, one RAND survey of baby boomers, generation X, and millennials found their views appeared to be driven more by age than by generation. Younger respondents were generally less concerned about security—and more concerned about economic/kitchen table issues—than older ones.

For a service largely composed of young adults, generational misconceptions may be food for thought. See the survey results online on RAND.org and a related National Academies report.

I also want to draw your attention to a new feature on our website: Research Competencies. You'll find summaries of our work in key policy areas such as Improving Workforce Diversity and Inclusion, Research on Air Force Health and Health Care, Research on Training and Development, and What Leaders Need to Know About Talent Management in the U.S. Air Force.

I look forward to your feedback: WDHNewsletter@rand.org

What our columnists are reading this month

    MILITARY HEALTH CARE

  • How the Supreme Court's abortion ruling can impact military readiness

    Miriam Matthews
    Associate director of the Workforce, Development, and Health program

    The Supreme Court's abortion ruling has obvious implications for the 40 percent of female service members stationed in states with strict limits on the procedure which DoD is trying to mitigate. Less obvious are the potential impacts on military readiness and national security. A recent RAND Perspective explains how the ruling could affect recruitment and retention, increase costs to the military from unplanned births (e.g., healthcare, childcare, education), and limit the number of members available to deploy, among other implications.

  • TALENT MANAGEMENT

  • What the Air Force can learn from years of recruiting research

    David Schulker
    Senior Policy Researcher

    FY 2022 was a tough recruiting year for the Air Force. The service struggled to reach its active component goals and fell short in the reserve component by 3,500 recruits. The situation is so dire that former Secretary of Defense Mark Esper has suggested that the all-volunteer force is "slowly dying." A recent RAND report that has collected years of Army recruiting research—unifying themes, implications, and recommendations—could be a valuable resource to help the Air Force Recruiting Service maximize recruiting effectiveness and efficiency in a difficult environment.

  • Waivers could help in today's tough recruiting market

    Beth Asch
    Senior Economist

    Fiscal year 2023 is expected to be another difficult recruiting year for the Air Force. The declining pool of eligible recruits, low propensity to serve, and favorable employment conditions persist. Expanded use of waivers that lets the service reconsider applicants who were initially disqualified could help the Air Force reach more recruits. Recent RAND research for the Army concluded that waivered recruits are not uniformly riskier and, along some dimensions, perform better. The key is understanding the characteristics of recruits who are more likely to do well and taking steps that can mitigate any poor performance outcomes.

  • CIVILIAN WORKFORCE

  • Improving talent management for knowledge workers

    Kirsten M. Keller
    Senior Behavioral Scientist

    Effective talent management of knowledge workers, who are often civilian, is critical to effective operations in the DAF. A recent RAND report reviewed and synthesized the results of more than 30 RAND Corporation studies on talent management of knowledge workers in the Department of Defense that could also help the DAF think about its own efforts. The report, which highlights key findings from recruiting to retention, found that issues with diversity and data management were themes that cut across the career lifecycle.

  • PERSONNEL SELECTION AND STANDARDS

  • RAND tool predicts diversity impacts of new officer promotion policy

    Maria Lytell
    Senior Behavioral Scientist

    The DAF is still implementing a new officer promotion system, designed to retain talented officers through better talent management and more transparency. But questions are already surfacing about how it will affect demographic diversity in the officer corps—questions that a new RAND tool is helping to answer. PAF's Air Force Personnel Policy Simulation Tool (PPST) suggests that the policy will likely improve officer diversity, but it indicates that more people at O-5 and O-6 grades will leave the service. The PPST could be valuable to help DAF leaders understand the impacts—before the policy is fully implemented.

  • TRAINING AND EDUCATION

  • Getting the services on the same page about joint all-domain C2

    Mark Toukan
    Political Scientist

    Anticipated changes in how warfare is conducted are driving the services to develop ways to speed decision-making in a joint, all-terrain command and control (JADC2) environment. But the concept is still evolving and lacks a universally agreed-upon definition. RAND researchers created a primer to help organizations inside and outside the Air Force (and the U.S. Department of Defense) gain a common understanding of how the effort to coordinate military operations across land and sea relates to future battlefield needs and to DAF's operational test and training infrastructure in particular.