Cover: Health Habit Counseling Amidst Competing Demands

Health Habit Counseling Amidst Competing Demands

Effects of Patient Health Habits and Visit Characteristics

Published in: Medical Care, v. 37, no. 8, Aug. 1999, p. 738-747

Posted on 1999

by Bruce A. Chernof, Scott E. Sherman, Andrew B. Lanto, Martin L. Lee, Elizabeth Yano, Lisa V. Rubenstein

OBJECTIVE. This study assesses the effects of competing demands, such as poor health habits or new medical problems, on health-habit counseling during a primary care visit. METHODS. The authors surveyed a consecutive sample of 1,259 patients visiting primary care clinicians at an academic VA medical center. Before the visit, patients reported their health status, health habits, and sociodemographics; immediately after the visit, patients reported reasons for the visit and whether they had been counseled about specific health habits. The authors scored visit acuity ranging from visits for unscheduled walk-in care or new medical problems to scheduled visits for check-ups or old problems. The authors defined counseling triggers as clinical indications for counseling about particular health habits (e.g., smoking). They developed a logistic model predicting primary care provider counseling during a visit. RESULTS. Over two-thirds of patients (68.9%) received some health habit counseling. Controlling for other independent variables, patients with more triggers were more likely to report being counseled. Counseling rates went up as visit acuity went down; patients with the lowest visit acuity having 67% greater odds of being counseled than patients with the highest visit acuity. CONCLUSIONS. Physicians set priorities for health-habit counseling during a visit based on patients' health habit problems or triggers; whether the visit is scheduled or walk-in; and whether the patient has new or acute problems. Future research about primary care performance of health habit counseling should account for these patient and visit characteristics, and prevention-oriented health care organizations should ensure access to scheduled check-up visits.

This report is part of the RAND external publication series. Many RAND studies are published in peer-reviewed scholarly journals, as chapters in commercial books, or as documents published by other organizations.

RAND is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis. RAND's publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors.