Health Insurance

Tradeoffs Revisited

Published in: Journal of Health Economics, v. 20, no. 2, Mar. 2001, p. 289-293

Posted on on January 01, 2001

by Willard G. Manning, M. Susan Marquis

Read More

Access further information on this document at

This article was published outside of RAND. The full text of the article can be found at the link above.

In two recent papers, (Journal of Health Economics 18(2), 141-152, Journal of Health Economics 18(6), 811-824) Nyman raised some questions about the welfare calculations and conclusions in an earlier paper (Manning and Marquis, Health insurance: the tradeoff between risk pooling and moral hazard, Vol. 15, 1996). This note discusses the erroneous criticisms in his papers. First, although, the authors estimated a Marshallian demand curve, their calculations are based on compensating variations that incorporate the gains from risk pooling. Second, their estimates of second best insurance plans indicate that some cost sharing is optimal, in contradiction to Nyman's his assertion that the authors' our results raise questions about the desirability of insurance coverage. The comment also deals with other issues raised by Nyman.

This report is part of the RAND Corporation External publication series. Many RAND studies are published in peer-reviewed scholarly journals, as chapters in commercial books, or as documents published by other organizations.

Our mission to help improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis is enabled through our core values of quality and objectivity and our unwavering commitment to the highest level of integrity and ethical behavior. To help ensure our research and analysis are rigorous, objective, and nonpartisan, we subject our research publications to a robust and exacting quality-assurance process; avoid both the appearance and reality of financial and other conflicts of interest through staff training, project screening, and a policy of mandatory disclosure; and pursue transparency in our research engagements through our commitment to the open publication of our research findings and recommendations, disclosure of the source of funding of published research, and policies to ensure intellectual independence. For more information, visit

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis. RAND's publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors.