Defining Mental Disorder

Differences in Primary Care Providers’ and Psychiatrists’ Conceptions of Illness

Skye A. Miner, Joshua Breslau, Charles C. Engel, Stacey Yi, Luke J. Matthews

ResearchPosted on rand.org Oct 21, 2026Published in: Journal of General Internal Medicine (2026). DOI: 10.1007/s11606-026-10906-5

Background

Increasingly primary care providers (PCPs) play a role in recognizing and diagnosing mental disorders. However, how PCPs conceptualize mental disorders within their patient population and how this conceptualization differs and aligns with a more psychiatric approach to mental disorder remains largely unknown.

Objective

To determine 1) how PCPs and psychiatrists describe their patients with suspected mental health conditions; 2) how PCPs and psychiatrists describe easy to treat and diagnose and challenging to treat and diagnose patients; and 3) how PCPs manage referrals to psychiatry.

Design

Online qualitative interviews.

Participants

41 PCPs and 41 psychiatrists. Participants were recruited from two health networks with different catchment areas: Cambridge Health Alliance is on the East coast and primarily serves urban and suburban patients. University of Washington is on the West coast and serves urban, suburban and rural patients.

Approach

The team performed a deductive analysis of the interview notes using a rapid framework analysis approach.

Key Results

PCPs and psychiatrists describe easy to treat and diagnose patients in similar ways. However, PCPs see complex psychiatric conditions like schizophrenia as more challenging. Those who felt more comfortable managing these complex patients had patients with access to psychiatric services or had access to e-consult services.

Conclusions

Examining the differences between PCPs and psychiatrists’ conceptualization of patients with mental health disorders highlights gaps in mental health care, including the need for PCPs and psychiatrists to collaborate. Collaborations like psychiatric e-consult services could help improve mental health care access, especially in rural areas, for more complex patients whose PCPs may need assistance with diagnosis or treatment management.

Topics

Document Details

  • Publisher: Springer Nature
  • Availability: Non-RAND
  • Year: 2026
  • Pages: 10
  • Document Number: EP-71527

Research conducted by

This publication is part of the RAND external publication series. Many RAND studies are published in peer-reviewed scholarly journals, as chapters in commercial books, or as documents published by other organizations.

RAND is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis. RAND's publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors.