Aug 16, 2006
In 2003, the U.S. Department of Defense (DoD) specified evolutionary acquisition (EA) as the preferred approach to weapon system acquisition, and spiral development as the preferred means of implementation. EA strategies aim to develop new capabilities in multiple increments, as opposed to the traditional strategy of developing a full capability in a single, lengthier step. EA strategies are meant to reduce the time it takes to field operationally useful equipment, control technical risk and cost growth, and make cost estimates more reliable for each stage of development, while allowing greater flexibility to evaluate and improve a program based on experience in the field. This greater flexibility arises in part from the fact that, with the spiral development approach, the end-state requirements are not known at program initiation, but rather emerge and evolve through an iterative process of phased development and operational testing. However, there is little documented evidence to assess the policy.
RAND Project AIR FORCE (PAF) has performed research to help the U.S. Air Force acquisition management community formulate cost analysis and program management policies that anticipate and respond to more widespread use of EA strategies. As part of this effort, PAF studied the implementation of EA concepts in five defense space acquisition programs. Space programs were chosen because they have recently grown in importance for the future of the Air Force, they are central to DoD's plans for transforming the U.S. armed forces, and they reflect the Air Force's recent review and overhaul of space acquisition policy to include the use of EA concepts. The case studies suggest the following conclusions:
There is a strong consensus among the cost analysts interviewed that EA is an important and useful tool that can benefit program managers if handled with care. Further research is needed to determine how EA can be implemented most effectively given the political, bureaucratic, and regulatory realities of the current acquisition environment.