Russian S-400 Surface-to-Air Missile System: Is It Worth the Sticker Price?
John Parachini, International/Defense Researcher
As countries around the globe struggle with the global pandemic, national leaders will face difficult spending decisions. Health care demands will inevitably stress national budgets, and this will pit domestic health care spending against national defense spending. The decision to buy expensive air defense systems like Russia's S-400 warrants a detailed analysis of alternatives.
The analysis of alternatives should not just consider other air defense systems, but should also consider other means to address the threat countries perceive. Russia is marketing the S-400 air defense system to countries all around the world, some of which have a questionable need for such a sophisticated system. What is often not appreciated by prospective buyers is that in order to be effective, the S-400 must be accompanied by other systems to detect incoming threats and defend against them. To make air defense systems effective, it requires radars on the ground and other short range missile systems to protect the S-400. The need for these additional systems increases the cost overall.
Moreover, having a networked, expensive air defense system requires a highly trained military workforce in order to operate it and maintain it. To achieve this level of sophisticated personnel, lots of training is required. Even with lots of training and a sophisticated network system, there are recent cases where drones and low flying cruise missiles defeated air defense systems. Thus, as countries think through decisions about how to meet their air defense needs, they should think through the options, consider alternatives, price them out carefully, but also consider other means that they might employ, such as diplomatic measures that might achieve the same security ends that they seek.
Many countries do not fully appreciate that effective air defense requires a networked system and not just one missile system component. Getting the true defensive value out of the S-400 surface-to-air system requires additional components that add costs and complexities.
Russia uses arms exports to further relations with other countries, influence their political and military leaders, and further its broader foreign and defense policy goals. A series of maps show the extent of its marketing, negotiating, and sales of key weapons systems.
Russia seeks to influence global policy through arms sales, the use of private military contractors, political interventions, social media and disinformation campaigns, and military force. A RAND project examines the workings of these levers of influence.
In response to recent Russian cyber espionage, interference in U.S. elections, and the poisoning of opposition leader Alexei Navalny, President Biden announced a new round of sanctions and expulsions of Russian officials. But will these sanctions hurt Russia's defense industry enough to curb the Kremlin's behavior?