Student Writing Accepted as High-Quality Responses to Analytic Text-Based Writing Tasks
Published in: The Elementary School Journal [ Volume 118, Number 3]. doi: 10.1086/696097
Posted on RAND.org on February 08, 2018
Read MoreAccess further information on this document at The Elementary School Journal [ Volume 118
This article was published outside of RAND. The full text of the article can be found at the link above.
Literacy standards increasingly emphasize the importance of analytic text-based writing. Little consensus exists, however, around what high-quality student responses should look like in this genre. In this study, we investigated fifth-grade students' writing in response to analytic text-based writing tasks (15 teachers, 44 writing tasks, 88 pieces of student writing). We used qualitative analytic techniques to investigate teachers' stated assessment criteria and to compare teachers' and researchers' assessments of student writing nominated by teachers as high quality. We then characterized patterns in students' responses. Our results showed no variation in teachers' stated assessment criteria but substantial variation in students' writing with respect to 3 researcher-defined elements: cognitive process, use of text evidence, and explication. Only 22% of student responses nominated by teachers as high quality were close to fully realizing the task potential.