Modernizing Puerto Rico's Housing Sector Following Hurricanes Irma and Maria

Post-Storm Challenges and Potential Courses of Action

by Noreen Clancy, Lloyd Dixon, Dan Elinoff, Kathryn Kuznitsky, Sean McKenna

Download

Download eBook for Free

Full Document

FormatFile SizeNotes
PDF file 3.7 MB

Use Adobe Acrobat Reader version 10 or higher for the best experience.

Research Summary

FormatFile SizeNotes
PDF file 0.3 MB

Use Adobe Acrobat Reader version 10 or higher for the best experience.

Purchase

Purchase Print Copy

 FormatList Price Price
Add to Cart Paperback168 pages $43.00 $34.40 20% Web Discount

Research Questions

  1. How did deficiencies in Puerto Rico's housing sector before the storms contribute to more broad-scale devastation and hinder disaster response after?
  2. What are the remaining needs for recovery of the Puerto Rico housing sector?
  3. How can Puerto Rico rebuild and modernize the housing market for greater resiliency?
  4. How can public, private, nonprofit, and academic stakeholders contribute to recovery and help Puerto Rico set itself on the path to successfully implement a transformative program for the housing sector?

Hurricanes Irma and Maria struck Puerto Rico in September 2017 with devastating impact. The housing sector was hard hit. The storms revealed in harsh detail the vulnerability of Puerto Rico's housing stock to wind, flood, and landslide risk and brought to light many inadequacies in the structure of the housing market.

Through a detailed and comprehensive analysis of the housing damage caused by the 2017 hurricanes, the authors make informed recovery recommendations for policymakers so they can repair and rebuild safe and affordable housing in Puerto Rico and create a modernized housing infrastructure that is more resilient to future natural hazards and code-compliant. The authors begin by examining the state of the Puerto Rico housing sector before Irma and Maria, using census data, detailed geospatial data sets of building footprints, parcel-level data on building characteristics and spatial flood zones, and interviews with Puerto Rico's housing stakeholders. To estimate the damage caused by the hurricanes and determine the post-disaster unmet need, they used two approaches, one based on actual property inspections and a second modeling approach that makes projections of damage based on wind and flood maps. The authors then offer courses of actions to address the remaining needs for recovery, detailing the costs of each action; potential funding mechanisms; and roles for public, private, nonprofit, and academic stakeholders in the housing market. Their recommendations will engage anyone implementing recovery activities in Puerto Rico or involved in community planning for, or recovering from, similar disasters.

Key Findings

Poor economic conditions and deficiencies in the structure of the housing market prestorm created and perpetuated problems post-disaster

  • Puerto Rico's housing stock was known to be vulnerable to wind, flooding, erosion, and landslide risk.
  • A substantial number of residential houses were built "informally" — without building permits, falling far short of building codes, and without insurance of any kind.
  • Existing programs to provide affordable housing are not big enough to meet demand.

Mechanisms for tracking, approving, and certifying property ownership were lacking

  • Inconsistent land-use plans meant that homes were sometimes built in high-risk areas.
  • Lack of clear property title, common in Puerto Rico, makes it difficult to distribute assistance after disasters and removes the property tax base needed to fund services.
  • Take-up rates for homeowners and flood insurance are low, leaving many without resources to pay for temporary shelter or to rebuild their homes.

Recovery efforts were impeded by lack of data and other challenges

  • There is no central source of data related to title, permits, land use, property tax, and location.
  • Lack of accessible data on sales and rentals has prohibited the development of consumer-based products, such as the Multiple Listing Service, to help find available housing.
  • Address numbers on streets are chaotic, with often multiple uses of the same street name in a community. This complexity hinders emergency response.
  • Other prestorm challenges included the high cost of getting building permits, high housing construction costs, increasing foreclosures, and increase in vacancy and blight as residents have emigrated from Puerto Rico.

Recommendations

Repair the housing stock and reduce its vulnerability to natural hazards

  • Start with substantially damaged owner-occupied structures to reduce the hardship caused by the storms. Residences without significant damage must be assessed to reduce their vulnerability in future storm events.
  • Mitigate damaged subsidized rental housing to be resilient to natural hazards and to accommodate special-needs populations, such as those with disabilities, seniors, and veterans.
  • Increase take-up rates of homeowners and renters insurance. Insurance will not prevent damage from a disaster, but it does provide resources to recover afterward.

Improve housing availability for lower-income households

  • Implement payment assistance programs to reduce mortgage delinquencies and foreclosures so homeowners can remain in their homes and avoid the social disruption of relocating.
  • Engage communities in strategies (e.g., rent to own, first-time homeowner programs) to rehabilitate properties and address the high vacancy rates across Puerto Rico.
  • Given the lack of funds for new construction of public housing and the long-term demand, tap public-private partnerships for creative financing to leverage private debt with limited public resources in smaller developments.

Modernize the housing market infrastructure

  • Decrease the time or monetary cost of compliance, and increase the actual benefits associated with the formal housing sector.
  • Collect, integrate, and map data on the housing sector to improve and standardize the irregularities in Puerto Rico's address system.
  • Enforce land-use plans, building permitting, and building codes by allocating resources for municipalities to develop land-use plans consistent with economic development and creating a pathway to bring noncompliant structures into compliance.

Table of Contents

  • Chapter One

    Introduction

  • Chapter Two

    Overview of Housing Sector and Prestorm Challenges

  • Chapter Three

    Hurricane Damage and Post-Storm and Remaining Needs

  • Chapter Four

    COA Development: An Overview

  • Chapter Five

    COAs That Repair and Reduce the Vulnerability of the Housing Stock

  • Chapter Six

    COAs That Improve Housing Availability for Lower-Income Households

  • Chapter Seven

    COAs That Modernize Housing Market Infrastructure

  • Chapter Eight

    Conclusion

  • Appendix A

    Case Study of the Housing Recovery Task Force

  • Appendix B

    Construction of Isolation Score

  • Appendix C

    Insurance Claims Following Hurricane Maria

  • Appendix D

    Estimates of Mitigation Cost

Research conducted by

This research was sponsored by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and conducted by the Strategy, Policy and Operations Program within Homeland Security Operational Analysis Center.

This report is part of the RAND Corporation research report series. RAND reports present research findings and objective analysis that address the challenges facing the public and private sectors. All RAND reports undergo rigorous peer review to ensure high standards for research quality and objectivity.

The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis. RAND's publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors.