- What issues may arise if women are integrated into the Marine Corps infantry?
- What efforts have been successful in addressing these issues in the past?
- What potential costs are likely to be associated with gender integration?
This study for the U.S. Marine Corps consisted of four tasks: (1) review the literature on the integration of women in ground combat and other physically demanding occupations, (2) conduct interviews with representatives of organizations that have integrated women into physically demanding occupations, (3) estimate the costs of potential initiatives to promote successful gender integration, and (4) develop an approach for monitoring implementation of gender integration of the infantry. RAND researchers present a historical overview of the integration of women into the U.S. military and explore the importance of cohesion and what influences it. The gender integration experiences of foreign militaries, as well as those of domestic police and fire departments, are examined for insights on effective policies. The potential one-time and recurring costs associated with integration are estimated as well. The report culminates in a summary of previous monitoring efforts and broad strategic monitoring issues, as well as recommendations to the Marine Corps for implementation.
Research Indicates Gender Integration Has Not Been a Primary Cause of Cohesion Problems
- In general, cohesion within gender-diverse groups improves over time.
- Cohesion should increase as women demonstrate the ability to perform at high levels.
- Negative impacts on cohesion can be prevented or mitigated by leadership and cohesion-building activities.
The Experiences of Foreign Militaries Provide Valuable Lessons
- Recruiting and retaining women for combat arms occupations can be challenging.
- Successful integration programs have a clear implementation plan.
- Human resource management policies need to support integration: Targeted recruitment and retention policies can attract women into combat arms occupations and retain them in those occupations.
- Leadership commitment and accountability are vital to successful gender integration.
Civilian Fire and Police Departments Provide Useful Insights
- Equipment and uniforms must meet the needs of women.
- Small-unit dynamics and discipline need to be closely monitored.
- Integration challenges change and mature over time.
There Will Be Both One-Time and Recurring Costs with Integration
- The number of women entering the infantry will be modest, and the increase in representation will be slow.
- Women will have higher levels of attrition during training and fewer months of infantry service than men, but overall costs are expected to be modest compared to recruiting and retention budgets.
- The Marine Corps will be able to make up any shortfall in the infantry effectively through increased recruitment, increased retention, or both.
- Leadership is key to integration success. Senior leaders are uniquely positioned to implement and enforce legal and policy changes needed to support integration. Leaders also set the command climate and enforce good order and discipline to prevent issues of misconduct that can have negative impacts on cohesion.
- Develop a detailed implementation plan and assign accountability. An implementation plan ensures that integration occurs alongside the necessary training, mentorship, monitoring, and institutional support. It is also important to assign responsibility and accountability for the various elements of the implementation plan.
- Establish oversight mechanisms to build trust, transparency, and accountability. Oversight mechanisms should include both internal monitoring to help ensure consistent institutional commitment, and external monitoring to provide objectivity, transparency, and accountability.
- Monitor standards and training. It is critical to continue to develop validated gender-neutral standards, update those standards and training, and enforce standards equally.
- Plan for long-term career progression issues. Integration challenges related to recruiting, hiring, promotion, and retention change over time as women advance in their careers.
- Develop integration strategies that best suit the Marine Corps through experimentation linked to data collection, analysis, and evaluation. These data, analyses, and evaluations are the building-blocks for monitoring integration and can also help refine the implementation plan and associated policies.
- Monitor integration progress over time. A strong monitoring plan relies on robust data systems that facilitate the necessary data collection to measure integration progress.
- Manage internal and external expectations, and ensure the planning process for integration is flexible enough to accommodate learning and adjustments.
Table of Contents
History of Integrating Women into the U.S. Military
Research on Cohesion
Insights on Critical Mass
Lessons Learned from the Experiences of Foreign Militaries
Lessons Learned from the Experiences of Domestic Police and Fire Departments
Integrating the Marine Corps Infantry: Representation and Costs
Developing a Monitoring Framework
Cross-Cutting Implications and Recommendations for Implementation
Rubric for Evaluating USMC Infantry Characteristics
Summary of FDNY Postintegration Lawsuits
Approach to Developing a Monitoring Framework
This research was sponsored by the United States Marine Corps and conducted within the Forces and Resources Policy Center of the RAND National Defense Research Institute, a federally funded research and development center sponsored by the Office of the Secretary of Defense, the Joint Staff, the Unified Combatant Commands, the Department of the Navy, the Marine Corps, the defense agencies, and the defense Intelligence Community.
This report is part of the RAND Corporation Research report series. RAND reports present research findings and objective analysis that address the challenges facing the public and private sectors. All RAND reports undergo rigorous peer review to ensure high standards for research quality and objectivity.
Permission is given to duplicate this electronic document for personal use only, as long as it is unaltered and complete. Copies may not be duplicated for commercial purposes. Unauthorized posting of RAND PDFs to a non-RAND Web site is prohibited. RAND PDFs are protected under copyright law. For information on reprint and linking permissions, please visit the RAND Permissions page.
The RAND Corporation is a nonprofit institution that helps improve policy and decisionmaking through research and analysis. RAND's publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors.